Hey everyone,

I hope this is the right mlist to post my question to. If not, please
redirect me to the correct one. I recently tried async for websockets.
Here's the question:


Looking at the following code, is there a better way to do it?

I personally find it much too much code for its purpose. Yet I cannot
think of an improvement because I am not used to the usual patterns in
async programming. What I find especially annoying is the boilerplate
code regarding the renewal of the consumed task object (initializing
with None, picking the last one or create a new one, resetting to None,
repeat).

If, due to the boilerplate, the intent is not clear, there are two
endlessly producing coroutines ("queue" & "receive") from which is being
read and reacted to, whatever comes first.




     notify_task = None
     event_task = None
     while True:
         notify_task = notify_task or asyncio.Task(queue.get())
         event_task = event_task or asyncio.Task(receive())
         done, pending = await asyncio.wait([notify_task, event_task],
return_when=asyncio.FIRST_COMPLETED)

         if notify_task in done:
             notify = notify_task.result()
             notify_task = None
             await handle_notify(scope, send, notify)

         if event_task in done:
             event = event_task.result()
             event_task = None
             if await handle_ws_default_protocol(scope, send, event,
conn, listen_callback):
                 break


Why am I asking?

Because a friend of mine also was a bit puzzled that this
"select.select"-type of programming is so verbose in async or if we were
just missing a crucial element.


Cheers and thanks you in advance for any answer,
Sven


PS:

What's the history of this code?

Reading different tutorials, both queues are discussed and implemented
separately (one is websocket, the other one is a message broker). Either
code examples were quiet small. But as soon as you want to plug both
together, the resulting code suddenly explodes and requires a lot of
manual handling as shown above. At least from my perception of "manual".

I do not blame these tutorials as they focus on either problem
separately. Still in real-world projects, different concepts frequently
need to be combined to make the whole idea work.

It took me quite some time to find a way to do it. The result above, I
find it neither readable nor explainable to other async-noobs like me.
Especially "asyncio.wait" was quite hidden in the library (and from
google) and it took me many iterations to understand how to interact
with it properly (although the obvious API is quite simple).


_______________________________________________
Async-sig mailing list -- async-sig@python.org
To unsubscribe send an email to async-sig-leave@python.org
https://mail.python.org/mailman3/lists/async-sig.python.org/
Code of Conduct: https://www.python.org/psf/codeofconduct/