Hello André, On Sat, Jan 24, 2015 at 5:23 PM, Andre Roberge <andre.roberge@gmail.com> wrote:
Why are you spamming the edu-sig list: you were replying to an email that was never sent to that list.
If that's to have people noting never to recommend Asymptopia software and autoteach.net, and actually tell people you consider them to be spammers, you can say "mission accomplished" as far as I am concerned.
André Roberge
Sorry for the misunderstanding. I was, in fact, responding to the following message from Sebastian Silva: from:Sebastian Silva <sebastian@fuentelibre.org> to:Charles Cossé < ccosse@gmail.com> cc:"edu-sig@python.org" <edu-sig@python.org> date:Fri, Jan 23, 2015 at 11:57 AMsubject:Re: [Edu-sig] (no subject):Important mainly because of your interaction with messages in the conversation. But you appear to be correct because I don't see this message in the edu-sig archives, which is also why I had a 3x post last week, ie because they appeared to be not going through. Perhaps there is something wrong with the edu-sig mailman daemon? Anyway, I've read many of your posts over the years, and as a Python user, developer and serious advocate of 15 years I do believe I am in the right place to discuss a non-commercial, open source product with "Python" and "Education" written all over it. I'm no spammer and I've worked very hard for several years to make this project a reality. I hope that it can advance Python, Parents and Open Source Education Software, all. I'm sure there is a misunderstanding somewhere here, but it's hard to trace if messages are being deleted from the queue or whatever is going on. Let's see if this goes through ... Best Regards, Charles
On Sat, Jan 24, 2015 at 8:17 PM, Charles Cossé <ccosse@gmail.com> wrote:
Thanks for keeping this discussion alive, Sebastian.
There are plenty of "portal" and LMS and such web software around. What is the need for a new one?
"You can lead a child to quality educational resources, but you can't make them care" -- *me* :) So, the credit-meter gets them to *care*. And not only *care*, but actually *ask* for more work ... math, science, geography, language, whatever ... they want internet access and it is suddenly in their interest to make an effort, regardless of material. I think that is the goal of any teacher, i.e. having students give a hoot about the material.
Also, I think "caring" is a prerequisite to real learning and retention. In my experience this form of "caring", i.e. caring about earning credits, is enough. They don't have to love math, but after they are compelled to "care" in this way, they still come-away with the information and the skills.
I think the following condensed overview is useful, and also *this new overview graphic <http://www.asymptopia.org/media/project_images/AutoTeachInfoGraphic.png>* :
This project is about teaching kids, first and foremost. It became web-based so I could create and assign lessons from my office. The credit-meter is what I was forced to resort to in order to get their attention. Soon I recognized the system's potential for any subject, and so made it possible for others to contribute. But how to get others to contribute? Money! I would have paid for this. Other parents probably would, too, but there would be trust issues on both sides, parents and developers. And it could be messy ... unless you let parent break-down and distribute their subscription fees to the developers of their choice. Trust issues solved, clear for take-off, next stop synergy!
In other words, how to handle "internet credit" and access control and portal provider, etc?
Well, the good news is that these have all been solved and the solutions are up-and-running. Portal provider ... I've got it running on a cloud server in San Jose, California. Subscription payments are handled through PayPal.
Here is the new user procedure: 1. Goto autoteach.net/subscribe and purchase a subscription. You can also buy the router pieces from me, and a pre-loaded SD card, or you can download the SD image from Github and buy the R-Pi & other pieces (antenna, power supply, case, SD) elsewhere. If you buy from me I will just send a box of parts, else if I assemble it would require FCC certification etc. So I'll send an instructions page along with. Anyway, the PayPal process redirects you back to autoteach.net, which auto-instantiates your parent account and sends you an email with your AccountID (=username, password).
2. You can immediately login and play around, but that's not required.
3. Assemble your R-Pi and boot-up the first time.
4. Navigate to 192.168.66.1 and you will see a Setup screen.
5. Enter the AccountID from the email and push "Setup".
6. Your R-Pi will pull your account info from autoteach.net, including all accounts you have setup there and your router configuration (default if you haven't logged into autoteach.net yet.)
At this point, if you have never yet logged-in to autoteach.net, then you've just sync'd with your lone parent account. The Username and Password for both your parent account online, as well as your parent account on the router, are all just = AccountID. AutoTeach.net is whitelisted by default, on the router, and the firewall is open by default as well.
You can configure everything on the router-side, but my colleague convinced me to spend 180 days implementing this web-sync capability, so now the recommended procedure is to do everything at autoteach.net and push the "sync" button on the router. It is much easier like this, indeed.
By default you can create one more parent account and 2 kid accounts.
Then, you the parent can login to autoteach.net from anywhere over-the-net and create assignments and assign to whichever kid(s) you want.
Your kids connect via the AutoTeach R-Pi router (at home) and visit autoteach.net (because it's whitelisted) ... they each have their own 2 accounts, one on the router, one on the autoteach.net site. When they login to autoteach.net they see their list of assignments and perform whatever they want, as per the way you have configured for them (i.e. repeatable, do this first, etc).
Once complete, then they login to 192.168.66.1 (AutoTeach R-Pi router at home) and push "Transfer Credit" ... which transfers the credits they've earned from the online site to their account on the router. Then they push "Connect" on their account interface at the router, and this causes the router to open-up the firewall to their list of WiFi devices (XBox, laptop, phone, etc) ... and they have full access for all devices until credits run dry .. then back to the "credit-feeder" website (i.e. autoteach.net) to take another assignment and earn more credits.
Really I assure you that it's more complicated in writing than actually doing it. I am gearing-up to make a couple short videos demonstrating all of the above.
This is turning into a short book ... so I'll AutoSilence myself ... in a moment ... :) ... but lastly, let me just add that my *Kickstarter <https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/2035655858/autoteach>* campaign is launched and there are 18 routers left. It's being sold at cost, possibly less than cost (!) .. in an effort to seed the parent community.
Also important to mention are the benefits of being web-based: No setup, no dependencies, platform-independent, always current, use from anywhere, parents can compel kids from work/office/beach, centralization and strength-in-numbers (ie. developers)
I also think the platform can serve as a "glue" between parent-users and plugin-developers, without which the two communities just drift separately.
Finally (I PROMISE): As a developer your open source application can be made available outside of AutoTeach. There's no lock-in or anything like that. It's just an additional revenue stream for you.
I hope that I HAVE NOT answered all your questions, such that you and others will continue to keep this conversation alive!! If you've made it reading this far then thank you! Hope to hear from more people on edu-sig. Don't be shy ...
Charles Cossé Asymptopia Software <http://www.asymptopia.org>
_______________________________________________ Edu-sig mailing list Edu-sig@python.org https://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/edu-sig
On Sat, Jan 24, 2015 at 8:51 PM, Charles Cossé <ccosse@gmail.com> wrote:
Hello André,
On Sat, Jan 24, 2015 at 5:23 PM, Andre Roberge <andre.roberge@gmail.com> wrote:
Why are you spamming the edu-sig list: you were replying to an email that was never sent to that list.
If that's to have people noting never to recommend Asymptopia software and autoteach.net, and actually tell people you consider them to be spammers, you can say "mission accomplished" as far as I am concerned.
André Roberge
Sorry for the misunderstanding. I was, in fact, responding to the following message from Sebastian Silva:
1. If you look in the mail archive, you will see that your posts have gone through. https://mail.python.org/pipermail/edu-sig/2015-January/author.html 2. If you do check, you will also see that the message you were replying to did NOT make it to the list. Including the list in a reply from a personal individual, and including a whole bunch of information about a commercial product in that message, is spam in my books, which is why I wrote you a PRIVATE 3. I wrote a message directly to you to address this fact, and do not appreciate you sending a reply to the entire list in return. If you need to reply to me, please do so privately in the future. André Roberge
Mr. Roberge, I have no interest in hostilities. On Sat, Jan 24, 2015 at 7:13 PM, Andre Roberge <andre.roberge@gmail.com> wrote:
2. If you do check, you will also see that the message you were replying to
did NOT make it to the list. Including the list in a reply from a personal individual, and including a whole bunch of information about a commercial product in that message, is spam in my books, which is why I ...
Exactly. It's a list admin issue. I replied to "all", and if Sebastian's message did not make it to edu-sig because edu-sig doesn't work then I suggest you focus your energy on finding a constructive solution to the real problem, i.e. the list daemon. Secondly, my "product" is not anything but a commercial product. Please contact me offline if you need further assistance understanding the concept. Thirdly: You have chosen to omit reference to Sebastian's email sent directly to yourself , myself, as well as edu-sig (again!), in which he already corrected your characterization of my project as SPAM. And since his message did not make it to edu-sig, here it is again: ----------------8<-------------- from:Sebastian Silva <sebastian@fuentelibre.org> to:Charles Cossé < ccosse@gmail.com>, Andre Roberge <andre.roberge@gmail.com>, "edu-sig@python.org" <edu-sig@python.org> date:Sat, Jan 24, 2015 at 6:28 PMsubject:Re: Fwd: [Edu-sig] (no subject):Important mainly because of your interaction with messages in the conversation. On Sat, Jan 24, 2015 at 6:28 PM, Sebastian Silva <sebastian@fuentelibre.org> wrote: Edu-sig sometimes doesn't let my messages go thru, frankly I think there is no mantainer or something. I've written about it to -owner but got no response. I don't think Charles's project is SPAM at all. I'm a pretty interested developer and parent. Regards, Sebastian ----------------8<-------------- Again, I have no interest in hostilities. My project is NOT COMMERCIAL and my post is not SPAM. It is intended to advance the state of open source education software in a constructive, transparent, open and absolutely *non-commercial* way. My apologies to edu-sig for these non-constructive digressions. Charles Cossé
participants (2)
-
Andre Roberge
-
Charles Cossé