On 05/07/2014 05:41 PM, Peter Shute wrote:
If it means that Reply vs Reply All work differently for list messages from different domains, will it only lead to users becoming hopelessly confused? Is there anyone who's already using this who could report on the reactions from users?
It depends. If your MUA offers 'reply to list' that works in all cases to just reply to the list.
Otherwise, if first_strip_reply-to is No and reply_goes_to_list is Poster, in the case of From: munging or wrapping, reply will go to the poster and the poster's original Reply-To: and reply-all will go to the list. This is slightly different from the un-munged/wrapped case in that if the poster had an original Reply-To: with a different address, the poster's From: will be included in 'reply', but basically it's unchanged in spirit - reply is to the poster and reply-all includes the list.
In the other cases, it is similar except, e.g. if reply_goes_to_list is This list, simple reply will address the poster as well as the list, but in most cases, the poster is a list member and would have gotten it anyway.
The intent is to make munged/wrapped behavior as close as possible to the un-munged/wrapped behavior except that exposing the poster's address takes priority.