Umbrella list and filter sub list members
Hi,
We are using Mailman version 2.1.15.
I have read everything I can find about filtering for a member of a sub list to send to an umbrella list and not have it moderated. However, it doesn't seem to work for me.
I was wondering if someone could comment on my setup to see where I might be going wrong.
I have two lists: Testlist@domain Testumbrella@domain
Testlist@ has me as a user; -- name@yahoo.com --There are no filters set on this list.
TestUmbrella@ has 1 member; --Testlist@domain I have tried many filter combinations but currently I have set
--Sender Filter --> Non-member filters --> accept_these_nonmembers has @Testlist -- -- I have tried @Testlist, Testlist@domain, ^@TestList, nothing
--Recipient Filter --> acceptable_alias has @Testlist -- -- same tries as Sender filter both independent and combined combinations.
My goal: A member of the sublist (Testlist@) posts to umbrella list (Testumbrealla@) and because they are a member of a sub list, Testumbrealla@ will let their message go to anyone/list subscribed to Testumbrella.
The way I have set it up seems to be how the FAQ says to do so, yet it keeps bouncing saying that my email is a non-member email. Most members will not have an email of the same DOMAIN as the list so filtering by domain is not acceptable. I would like to not have to individually add each member of any sublist under an umbrella to the accetable members filters but that is what it is looking like.
Am I filtering incorrectly? Can I accomplish my goal?
Thanks for any help, David Dammann
On 05/20/2014 02:50 PM, Hathawulf Spearbreaker wrote:
This is accept_these_nonmembers set for the TestUmbrella list.
@Testlist or @testlist should work unless this is cPanel, in which case it needs to be @testlist_domain (i.e. the cPanel internal list name prefixed with '@')
Can you post to testlist?
--Recipient Filter --> acceptable_alias has @Testlist -- -- same tries as Sender filter both independent and combined combinations.
This is acceptable_aliases set for the Testlist list.
It should be Testumbrella@domain, but just Testumbrella should work.
It should work for what you have. Later if you have more lists as members of the umbrella, you may have an issue that sublist1 does not accept a post from the umbrella from a member of sublist2. This is addressed in the FAQ at <http://wiki.list.org/x/boA9>.
-- Mark Sapiro <mark@msapiro.net> The highway is for gamblers, San Francisco Bay Area, California better use your sense - B. Dylan
I am using CPanel.
Thanks for the info, that works great. I must have missed that someone in the FAQ's.
-David Dammann
On 05/20/2014 02:50 PM, Hathawulf Spearbreaker wrote:
This is accept_these_nonmembers set for the TestUmbrella list.
@Testlist or @testlist should work unless this is cPanel, in which case it needs to be @testlist_domain (i.e. the cPanel internal list name prefixed with '@')
Can you post to testlist?
--Recipient Filter --> acceptable_alias has @Testlist -- -- same tries as Sender filter both independent and combined combinations.
This is acceptable_aliases set for the Testlist list.
It should be Testumbrella@domain, but just Testumbrella should work.
It should work for what you have. Later if you have more lists as members of the umbrella, you may have an issue that sublist1 does not accept a post from the umbrella from a member of sublist2. This is addressed in the FAQ at <http://wiki.list.org/x/boA9>.
-- Mark Sapiro <mark@msapiro.net> The highway is for gamblers, San Francisco Bay Area, California better use your sense - B. Dylan
I am using CPanel.
Thanks for the info, that works great. I must have missed that someone in the FAQ's.
-David Dammann
participants (2)
-
Hathawulf Spearbreaker -
Mark Sapiro