Hi Robert,
are you using any package which relies on cpyext? I.e., modules written in C and/or with Cython (cffi is fine).
IIRC, at the moment PyPy doesn't detect GC cycles which involve cpyext objects.
So if you have a cycle which does e.g. 
    Py_foo -> C_bar -> Py_foo
(where Py_foo is a pure-python object and C_bar a cpyext object) they will never be collected unless you break the cycle manually.

Other than that: have you tried running it with PyPy 7.0 and/or 7.1?


On Thu, Mar 28, 2019 at 8:35 AM Robert Whitcher <robert.whitcher@rubrik.com> wrote:
So I have a process that use PyPy and pymongo in a loop.
It does basically the same thing every loop, which query a table in via pymongo and do a few non-save calculations and then wait and loop again 

The RSS of the process continually increased (the PYPY_GC_MAX is set pretty high).
So I hooked in the GC stats output per: http://doc.pypy.org/en/latest/gc_info.html
I also assure that gc.collect() was called at least every 3 minutes.

What I see is that... The memory while high is fair constant for a long time:
2019-03-27 00:04:10.033-0600 [-] main_thread(29621)log (async_worker_process.py:304): INFO_FLUSH: RSS: 144244736
...
2019-03-27 01:01:46.841-0600 [-] main_thread(29621)log (async_worker_process.py:304): INFO_FLUSH: RSS: 144420864
2019-03-27 01:02:36.943-0600 [-] main_thread(29621)log (async_worker_process.py:304): INFO_FLUSH: RSS: 144269312

Then it decides (an the exact per-loop behavior is the same each time) to chew up much more memory:

2019-03-27 01:04:17.184-0600 [-] main_thread(29621)log (async_worker_process.py:304): INFO_FLUSH: RSS: 145469440
2019-03-27 01:05:07.305-0600 [-] main_thread(29621)log (async_worker_process.py:304): INFO_FLUSH: RSS: 158175232
2019-03-27 01:05:57.401-0600 [-] main_thread(29621)log (async_worker_process.py:304): INFO_FLUSH: RSS: 173191168
2019-03-27 01:06:47.490-0600 [-] main_thread(29621)log (async_worker_process.py:304): INFO_FLUSH: RSS: 196943872
2019-03-27 01:07:37.575-0600 [-] main_thread(29621)log (async_worker_process.py:304): INFO_FLUSH: RSS: 205406208
2019-03-27 01:08:27.659-0600 [-] main_thread(29621)log (async_worker_process.py:304): INFO_FLUSH: RSS: 254562304
2019-03-27 01:09:17.770-0600 [-] main_thread(29621)log (async_worker_process.py:304): INFO_FLUSH: RSS: 256020480
2019-03-27 01:10:07.866-0600 [-] main_thread(29621)log (async_worker_process.py:304): INFO_FLUSH: RSS: 289779712

That's 140 MB .... Where is all that memory going...
What's more is that the PyPy GC stats do not show anything different:

Here are the GC stats from GC-Complete when we were at 144MB:

2019-03-26 23:55:49.127-0600 [-] main_thread(29621)log (async_worker_process.py:304): INFO_FLUSH: RSS: 140632064
2019-03-26 23:55:49.133-0600 [-] main_thread(29621)log (async_worker_process.py:308): DBG0: Total memory consumed:
            GC used:            56.8MB (peak: 69.6MB)
               in arenas:            39.3MB
               rawmalloced:          14.5MB
               nursery:              3.0MB
            raw assembler used: 521.6kB
            -----------------------------
            Total:              57.4MB

            Total memory allocated:
            GC allocated:            63.0MB (peak: 71.2MB)
               in arenas:            43.9MB
               rawmalloced:          22.7MB
               nursery:              3.0MB
            raw assembler allocated: 1.0MB
            -----------------------------
            Total:                   64.0MB

Here are the GC stats from GC-Complete when we are at 285MB:

2019-03-27 01:42:41.751-0600 [-] main_thread(29621)log (async_worker_process.py:304): INFO_FLUSH: RSS: 285147136
2019-03-27 01:42:41.751-0600 [-] main_thread(29621)log (async_worker_process.py:308): DBG0: Total memory consumed:
            GC used:            57.5MB (peak: 69.6MB)
               in arenas:            39.9MB
               rawmalloced:          14.6MB
               nursery:              3.0MB
            raw assembler used: 1.5MB
            -----------------------------
            Total:              58.9MB

            Total memory allocated:
            GC allocated:            63.1MB (peak: 71.2MB)
               in arenas:            43.9MB
               rawmalloced:          22.7MB
               nursery:              3.0MB
            raw assembler allocated: 2.0MB
            -----------------------------
            Total:                   65.1MB

How is this possible?

I am measuring RSS with:

def get_rss_mem_usage():
    '''
    Get the RSS memory usage in bytes
    @return: memory size in bytes; -1 if error occurs
    '''
    try:
        process = psutil.Process(os.getpid())
        return process.get_memory_info().rss
    except:
        return -1

And cross referencing with "ps -orss -p <pid>" and the RSS values reported are correct....

I cannot figure out where to go from here with this as it appears that PyPy is leaking this memory somehow...
And I have no idea howto proceed from here...
I end up having memory problems and getting Memory Warnings for a process that just loops and queries via pymongo
Pymongo version is 3.7.1

This is:

Python 2.7.13 (ab0b9caf307db6592905a80b8faffd69b39005b8, Apr 30 2018, 08:21:35)
[PyPy 6.0.0 with GCC 7.2.0]


_______________________________________________
pypy-dev mailing list
pypy-dev@python.org
https://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/pypy-dev