Re: [python-committers] Survey about DVCSs compared to svn
No need for a long answer - just explain what the purpose of the survey is, and why it isn't as biasad as it appears to be. A process where you're actively discouraging people with a certain opinion from getting involved isn't much of a process.
</F>
On Feb 27, 2009 9:24 PM, "Brett Cannon" brett@python.org wrote:
I had a long reply all written out, but instead I decided to discard it so as to not continue to drag this discussion out. Why? The DVCS PEP is not even finished yet!
Can you guys please let me finish the PEP before you start worrying about whether we are going to switch? At least give me the chance to make a decision on whether I think it is reasonable to switch and what to switch to. And then we can have a reasonable conversation where I update the PEP to address any questions that come up.
-Brett
On Fri, Feb 27, 2009 at 02:59, Fredrik Lundh fredrik@pythonware.com wrote:
On Fri, Feb 27, ...
The survey isn't biased. You have a value "the same /worse than the status
quo" - wherein the status quo is subversion. If you hate DVCes, you mark it
as "same/worse than the status quo" and we move on.
No one is suggesting we accept *less* functionality than subversion: in
fact we're looking at these for *more* functionality.
On Feb 27, 2009 7:04pm, Fredrik Lundh fredrik@pythonware.com wrote:
No need for a long answer - just explain what the purpose of the survey
is, and why it isn't as biasad as it appears to be. A process where
you're actively discouraging people with a certain opinion from getting
involved isn't much of a process.
On Feb 27, 2009 9:24 PM, "Brett Cannon" brett@python.org> wrote:
I had a long reply all written out, but instead I decided to discard it
so as to not continue to drag this discussion out. Why? The DVCS PEP is
not even finished yet!
Can you guys please let me finish the PEP before you start worrying about
whether we are going to switch? At least give me the chance to make a
decision on whether I think it is reasonable to switch and what to switch
to. And then we can have a reasonable conversation where I update the PEP
to address any questions that come up.
-Brett
On Fri, Feb 27, 2009 at 02:59, Fredrik Lundh fredrik@pythonware.com>
wrote:On Fri, Feb 27, ...
On Fri, Feb 27, 2009 at 16:04, Fredrik Lundh fredrik@pythonware.com wrote:
No need for a long answer - just explain what the purpose of the survey is,
To see what committers think about the various DVCSs and if one happens to be disliked by a majority of developer when compared to svn as a baseline.
and why it isn't as biasad as it appears to be. A process where you're actively discouraging people with a certain opinion from getting involved isn't much of a process.
I just wanted some data, nothing more. This was not meant to spark a debate else this would have occurred over at python-dev. I just wanted to know what people thought in order to potentially eliminate a DVCS from the running to make my life easier in writing the PEP. Next time I will flat-out write "DO NOT TAKE THIS SURVEY SERIOUSLY" and still hope people take the time to fill it out.
-Brett
</F> > > On Feb 27, 2009 9:24 PM, "Brett Cannon" <brett@python.org> wrote: > > I had a long reply all written out, but instead I decided to discard it so > as to not continue to drag this discussion out. Why? The DVCS PEP is not > even finished yet! > > Can you guys please let me finish the PEP before you start worrying about > whether we are going to switch? At least give me the chance to make a > decision on whether I think it is reasonable to switch and what to switch > to. And then we can have a reasonable conversation where I update the PEP to > address any questions that come up. > > -Brett > > On Fri, Feb 27, 2009 at 02:59, Fredrik Lundh <fredrik@pythonware.com> > wrote: > > On Fri, Feb 27, ... > >
participants (3)
-
Brett Cannon -
Fredrik Lundh -
jnoller＠gmail.com