Re: [Python-Dev] Paul Prescod: add Expat to 1.6
Recently, Skip Montanaro
Andrew> My personal leaning is that we can get more bang for the buck by Andrew> working on the Distutils effort, so that installing a package Andrew> like PyExpat becomes much easier, rather than piling more things Andrew> into the core distribution.
Amen to that. See Guido's note and my response regarding soundex in the Doc-SIG. Perhaps you could get away with a very small core distribution that only contained the stuff necessary to pull everything else from the net via http or ftp...
I don't know whether this subject belongs on the python-dev list (is there a separate distutils list?), but let's please be very careful with this. The Perl people apparently think that their auto-install stuff is so easy to use that if you find a tool on the net that needs Perl they'll just give you a few incantations you need to build the "correct" perl to run the tool, but I've never managed to do so. My last try was when I spent 2 days to try and get the perl-based Palm software for unix up and running. With various incompatilble versions of perl installed in /usr/local by the systems staff and knowing nothing about perl I had to give up at some point, because it was costing far more time (and diskspace:-) than the whole thing was worth. Something like mailman is (afaik) easy to install for non-pythoneers because it only depends on a single, well-defined Python distribution. -- Jack Jansen | ++++ stop the execution of Mumia Abu-Jamal ++++ Jack.Jansen@oratrix.com | ++++ if you agree copy these lines to your sig ++++ www.oratrix.nl/~jack | see http://www.xs4all.nl/~tank/spg-l/sigaction.htm
Skip> Amen to that. See Guido's note and my response regarding soundex Skip> in the Doc-SIG. Perhaps you could get away with a very small core Skip> distribution that only contained the stuff necessary to pull Skip> everything else from the net via http or ftp... Jack> I don't know whether this subject belongs on the python-dev list Jack> (is there a separate distutils list?), but let's please be very Jack> careful with this. The Perl people apparently think that their Jack> auto-install stuff is so easy to use ... I suppose I should have added a <0.5 wink> to my note. Still, knowing what Guido does and doesn't feel comfortable with in the core distribution would be a good start at seeing where we might like the core to wind up. Skip Montanaro | http://www.mojam.com/ skip@mojam.com | http://www.musi-cal.com/~skip/ 518-372-5583
[large vs small distributions] [Jack Jansen]
I don't know whether this subject belongs on the python-dev list (is there a separate distutils list?), but let's please be very careful with this. [and recounts his problems with Perl]
I must say the idea of a minimal distribution sounds very appealing. But then I consider that Guido never got me to even try Tk until he put it into the std Windows distribution, and I've never given anyone any code that won't work with a fresh-from-the-box distribution either. FrankS's snappy "batteries included" wouldn't carry quite the same punch if it got reduced to "coupons for batteries hidden in the docs" <wink>. OTOH, I've got about as much use for XML as MarkH has for continuations <twist>, and here-- as in many other places --we've been saved so far by Guido's good judgment about what goes in & what stays out. So it's a good thing he can't ever resign this responsibility <wink>. if-20%-of-users-need-something-i'd-include-it-else-not-ly y'rs - tim
participants (3)
-
Jack Jansen
-
Skip Montanaro
-
Tim Peters