On 31Mar2014 08:37, Nick Coghlan firstname.lastname@example.org wrote:
On 31 Mar 2014 08:22, "Cameron Simpson" email@example.com wrote:
Please tell me Mailman3 still includes the pipermail stuff still.
Mailman3 includes a pluggable archiver model - that's how HyperKitty can be a separate project, specifically aimed at tackling the "seamless web gateway" problem.
If it can be run in parallel, fine. If it replaces pipermail, it looks like a step backwards.
That gets me:
local search of local data access when offline, privacy, speed, whatever tools or indices I prefer
search tools of my choosing (eg mairix or mu), including the search facilities of my mail reader
using my mail reader search lets me read messages in my _preferred_ form, as it would for anyone else using their preferrer mail reader
Without an archive download, this is all far far less useful.
The pluggable archiver model in MM3 means HyperKitty itself doesn't need to handle that usage model. However, I'm not aware of any current efforts to create an MM3 archiver that is closer to a pure pipermail replacement (the workflow you describe strikes me as being incredibly unusual these days, as it requires either running your own mail server, or only accessing your email from one device)
My workflow is unusual only because most people don't think about it and because the existing MUAs do not make it easy. There _should_ be a "join a mailing list" button with optional archive suck.
Most modern MUAs have a "search my mail" facility. Making the raw list archive hard to obtain gets in the way of offering the user's own search field for search.
_Nothing_ in my workflow requires running my own mail server, it merely requires having local folders; which is entirely reasonable with an IMAP service, and entirely reasonable with multiple devices.
Using one's own search tools is only unusual because unless you're a nerd it is hard.
Likewise, sucking down the archives is difficult for end users for various reasons:
None of these is hard to address. I do it with a tiny shell script, but that is not for most people.
I still content that any change that removes the simple ability to fetch the list archive for use by the end user is a huge step backwards, regardless of the prettiness of whatever replaces it.
Cameron Simpson firstname.lastname@example.org
Early to bed and early to rise makes a man healthy and wealthy with bags under his eyes. - Dave Cochran, email@example.com