issue disambiguating overloaded method that takes an array
Hello everyone, This is probably a total n00b question, but I've been using pythonnet in our toolchain to communicate with a private c# assembly for months now without ever running into a problem I couldn't eventually figure out. This one has me totally stumped, and I'm hoping something obvious will jump out at experienced eyes. (I did a find/replace for secrecy, besides silly names these are the raw results I get back) A C# class exposes a method 'WriteByte' that has 5 overloads (note that only one of them takes 2 arguments):
accessor= MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeTypeArrayAccessor accessor.WriteByte.__overloads__ Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Byte[]) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Byte[], Int32 ByRef) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable`1[System.Byte], Int32 ByRef) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Int32, System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable`1[System.Byte], Int32 ByRef) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Int32, Byte[], Int32 ByRef)
I attempt to disambiguate by selecting the 2-arg method I want by type:
desired_method= accessor.WriteByte.__overloads__[MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, System.Array[System.Byte]]
The problem may be right here - if I print out desired_method.__doc__ I get the same 5 methods listed above. Anyway, then I compute my arguments, and can verify they have the types I expect (If it matters, arg_b is created by a call to System.IO.BinaryReader.ReadBytes()):
arg_a= ... arg_b= ... type(arg_a)
type(arg_b)
However, when I try to call the disambiguated method with the correct args, I get no love:
result= desired_method(arg_a, arg_b) Traceback (most recent call last): File "<string>", line 1, in <fragment> TypeError: No method matches given arguments
Does anyone see the obvious thing I'm doing wrong? Disambiguating can be a pain but I've done it before for other methods and have never had such an impossible time getting the correct method called. Thanks, Adrian Perez
def TestCharArray(): from System import Array charArrType = Array[Char] ##arrType = charArrType('hello') ##for char in arrType: ## print char, ## Also works on instances of the type! ## strCharArr = s.__overloads__[charArrType] s = strCharArr(list('hello')) print s On 5/16/2011 6:29 PM, Adrian Perez wrote:
Hello everyone,
This is probably a total n00b question, but I've been using pythonnet in our toolchain to communicate with a private c# assembly for months now without ever running into a problem I couldn't eventually figure out. This one has me totally stumped, and I'm hoping something obvious will jump out at experienced eyes.
(I did a find/replace for secrecy, besides silly names these are the raw results I get back)
A C# class exposes a method 'WriteByte' that has 5 overloads (note that only one of them takes 2 arguments):
accessor= MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeTypeArrayAccessor accessor.WriteByte.__overloads__ Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Byte[]) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Byte[], Int32 ByRef) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable`1[System.Byte], Int32 ByRef) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Int32, System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable`1[System.Byte], Int32 ByRef) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Int32, Byte[], Int32 ByRef)
I attempt to disambiguate by selecting the 2-arg method I want by type:
desired_method= accessor.WriteByte.__overloads__[MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, System.Array[System.Byte]] The problem may be right here - if I print out desired_method.__doc__ I get the same 5 methods listed above. Anyway, then I compute my arguments, and can verify they have the types I expect (If it matters, arg_b is created by a call to System.IO.BinaryReader.ReadBytes()):
arg_a= ... arg_b= ... type(arg_a)
type(arg_b) However, when I try to call the disambiguated method with the correct args, I get no love:
result= desired_method(arg_a, arg_b) Traceback (most recent call last): File "<string>", line 1, in<fragment> TypeError: No method matches given arguments
Does anyone see the obvious thing I'm doing wrong? Disambiguating can be a pain but I've done it before for other methods and have never had such an impossible time getting the correct method called.
Thanks,
Adrian Perez _________________________________________________ Python.NET mailing list - PythonDotNet@python.org http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/pythondotnet
from System import String, Char, Int32 def TestCharArray(): from System import Array charArrType = Array[Char] ##arrType = charArrType('hello') ##for char in arrType: ## print char, ## Also works on instances of the type! ## strCharArr = String.__overloads__[charArrType] s = strCharArr(list('hello')) print s TestCharArray() On 5/17/2011 12:38 AM, Barton wrote:
def TestCharArray(): from System import Array charArrType = Array[Char] ##arrType = charArrType('hello') ##for char in arrType: ## print char, ## Also works on instances of the type! ## strCharArr = s.__overloads__[charArrType] s = strCharArr(list('hello')) print s
On 5/16/2011 6:29 PM, Adrian Perez wrote:
Hello everyone,
This is probably a total n00b question, but I've been using pythonnet in our toolchain to communicate with a private c# assembly for months now without ever running into a problem I couldn't eventually figure out. This one has me totally stumped, and I'm hoping something obvious will jump out at experienced eyes.
(I did a find/replace for secrecy, besides silly names these are the raw results I get back)
A C# class exposes a method 'WriteByte' that has 5 overloads (note that only one of them takes 2 arguments):
accessor= MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeTypeArrayAccessor accessor.WriteByte.__overloads__ Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Byte[]) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Byte[], Int32 ByRef) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable`1[System.Byte], Int32 ByRef) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Int32, System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable`1[System.Byte], Int32 ByRef) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Int32, Byte[], Int32 ByRef)
I attempt to disambiguate by selecting the 2-arg method I want by type:
desired_method= accessor.WriteByte.__overloads__[MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, System.Array[System.Byte]] The problem may be right here - if I print out desired_method.__doc__ I get the same 5 methods listed above. Anyway, then I compute my arguments, and can verify they have the types I expect (If it matters, arg_b is created by a call to System.IO.BinaryReader.ReadBytes()):
arg_a= ... arg_b= ... type(arg_a)
type(arg_b) However, when I try to call the disambiguated method with the correct args, I get no love:
result= desired_method(arg_a, arg_b) Traceback (most recent call last): File "<string>", line 1, in<fragment> TypeError: No method matches given arguments
Does anyone see the obvious thing I'm doing wrong? Disambiguating can be a pain but I've done it before for other methods and have never had such an impossible time getting the correct method called.
Thanks,
Adrian Perez _________________________________________________ Python.NET mailing list - PythonDotNet@python.org http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/pythondotnet
Thank you for the snippets. I had poured over the unit tests and seen similar examples of how to do this already, but two commentless replies inspired me to trace through this in a debugger. The issue ended up being that I was erroneously under the impression I was calling a static method, and was retrieving the method off of the 'type' object, rather than an instance of the type. The error you get back is the generic "no method matches given arguments", because my local 'desired_method' expected an initial 'self' argument, and so silently took 'arg_a' to be 'self'. This meant MethodBinder.Bind() only thought it had 1 input argument and could not match it to any of the overloads. Cheers, Adrian Perez -----Original Message----- From: BCline [mailto:bcline3078@charter.net] Sent: Tuesday, May 17, 2011 12:56 AM Cc: Adrian Perez; pythondotnet@python.org Subject: Re: [Python.NET] issue disambiguating overloaded method UPDATE from System import String, Char, Int32 def TestCharArray(): from System import Array charArrType = Array[Char] ##arrType = charArrType('hello') ##for char in arrType: ## print char, ## Also works on instances of the type! ## strCharArr = String.__overloads__[charArrType] s = strCharArr(list('hello')) print s TestCharArray() On 5/17/2011 12:38 AM, Barton wrote:
def TestCharArray(): from System import Array charArrType = Array[Char] ##arrType = charArrType('hello') ##for char in arrType: ## print char, ## Also works on instances of the type! ## strCharArr = s.__overloads__[charArrType] s = strCharArr(list('hello')) print s
On 5/16/2011 6:29 PM, Adrian Perez wrote:
Hello everyone,
This is probably a total n00b question, but I've been using pythonnet in our toolchain to communicate with a private c# assembly for months now without ever running into a problem I couldn't eventually figure out. This one has me totally stumped, and I'm hoping something obvious will jump out at experienced eyes.
(I did a find/replace for secrecy, besides silly names these are the raw results I get back)
A C# class exposes a method 'WriteByte' that has 5 overloads (note that only one of them takes 2 arguments):
accessor= MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeTypeArrayAccessor accessor.WriteByte.__overloads__ Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Byte[]) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Byte[], Int32 ByRef) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable`1[System.Byte], Int32 ByRef) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Int32, System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable`1[System.Byte], Int32 ByRef) Boolean WriteByte(MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, Int32, Byte[], Int32 ByRef)
I attempt to disambiguate by selecting the 2-arg method I want by type:
desired_method= accessor.WriteByte.__overloads__[MyCompany.SomeNamespace.SomeType, System.Array[System.Byte]] The problem may be right here - if I print out desired_method.__doc__ I get the same 5 methods listed above. Anyway, then I compute my arguments, and can verify they have the types I expect (If it matters, arg_b is created by a call to System.IO.BinaryReader.ReadBytes()):
arg_a= ... arg_b= ... type(arg_a)
type(arg_b) However, when I try to call the disambiguated method with the correct args, I get no love:
result= desired_method(arg_a, arg_b) Traceback (most recent call last): File "<string>", line 1, in<fragment> TypeError: No method matches given arguments
Does anyone see the obvious thing I'm doing wrong? Disambiguating can be a pain but I've done it before for other methods and have never had such an impossible time getting the correct method called.
Thanks,
Adrian Perez _________________________________________________ Python.NET mailing list - PythonDotNet@python.org http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/pythondotnet
participants (3)
-
Adrian Perez -
Barton -
BCline