Re: [scikit-image] Fast Radial Symmetry Transform
Hi Alex! Thanks for writing and welcome! I hate to be discouraging, but from my perspective, I would be cautious about accepting this in scikit-image. My initial reaction to your email was very positive, but after a cursory skim of the paper I thought that it seemed like a pretty complicated algorithm, and most of the highly cited citations were survey papers, rather than cool applications. This isn’t a straight no, just that I would want to see a recent, complete application of the algorithm that I would find compelling enough. Then we could turn that into a gallery example, which would point users to this algorithm. Otherwise, I fear that it would languish and struggle to find future maintainers. There are a couple of parts of the library like this already, and they are a significant burden. I’m just one person though, and feel free to try to convince me otherwise! Juan.
participants (1)
-
Juan Nunez-Iglesias