I think you mean keyword-only, Alex
Yes I am +1 for positional arguments for
the __init__ of the estimators.
Alex
Albert: my position when reviewing changes in
accordance with this SLEP would be to (a) perhaps get usage
evidence as discussed in the SLEP pull request review; and (b)
apply a rule of thumb like "are the semantics reasonably clear
when the argument is passed positionally?" I think they are
clear for PCA's components, for Pipeline's steps, and for
GridSearchCV's estimator and parameter grid. Other parameters
of those estimators seem more suitable for keyword-only.