Hello,

As of today, there is no way to configure yt plots per-field. One is stuck with configuration that are yt-wide (e.g. default_colormap). For example, I often find myself typing p.set_cmap('density', 'dusk'). I suggest to add a way to configure the behaviour of yt plotting interface per-field using yt configuration, so that I could set once and for all some defaults for plots. I pushed a first PR on github (https://github.com/yt-project/yt/pull/1931) and opened an issue (https://github.com/yt-project/yt/issues/1888) to discuss the feature.

Nathan and I discussed a bit about how this should be implemented in the configuration file. Since ini files are quite restricted (e.g. you cannot have subsections), Nathan suggested at one point to use the toml format (https://github.com/toml-lang/toml). However, it is incompatible with the older .ini format. For example, boolean should be in lowercase (true, false) and not Python-like (True, False), strings have to be surrounded by apostrophes, ...

Another suggestion is to add each fields' configuration as a new section in the ini file. For example

[config.field_type.field_name]
cmap = viridis
log = False

This is what is implemented in the PR, but maybe some of you have more clever ideas about this? One fairly strong constraint is that the configuration files should be as backward-compatible as possible. If not, we'd have to write a migration script from the old to the new format.

We should also discuss what can be configured here. There is already the colormap and log scale implemented. One very neat feature would be to be able to configure the default unit, but it may be hard to implement (e.g. how do we configure the default unit for both projection and slices?) and probably confusing for the user.

So here are the questions. Do you think per-field configuration should be part of yt? If so what format should it use? And what are your thoughts on what should and shouldn't be configurable?

Corentin

-- 
Corentin Cadiou
PhD student
Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris (IAP), desk 142b
98 bis boulevard Arago
75014 Paris, France

phone: +33.6.43.18.66.83