[AstroPy] proposal for astropy version control software and respository

Phil Hodge hodge at stsci.edu
Mon Jul 18 08:56:55 EDT 2011


On 07/16/2011 09:20 AM, Thomas Robitaille wrote:
> Hi Peter,
>
> I understand your concerns that this might seem premature - just to
> explain our motives behind a yes/no poll at this stage: we got the
> impression from previous discussions on this list and from the
> discussions and success stories at scipy that this was something that
> most people would either agree with, or not have a strong opinion
> about. We can have had a lengthy debate about the detailed advantages
> of git vs hg vs svn vs other if needed, but we wanted to see whether
> that debate could be avoided in the first place if most people agreed
> anyway, hence the early poll (think of it as testing the waters). But
> we do want people to voice concerns or questions if you have any!  ...

Testing the waters?  If 10 people vote (only 10), and all vote for 
git/github, would that be interpreted as meaning our toes are wet, or we 
all (not just the ones who voted) jumped in head first?

Phil



More information about the AstroPy mailing list