[C++-sig] Quick question about wrapping methods that have multiple versions

Nicolas Lelong nico_ml at mgdesign.org
Wed Sep 9 12:15:09 CEST 2009

> You may disambiguate by using a cast inside .def(), such as
>   .def("getA", (A*(B::*)())B::getA);
>  Whether that's actually more readable is arguable, however.

IMHO, this is quite dangerous as the explicit cast prevents the compiler to 
give you a proper error if the signature of B::getA changes at some point in 
time. The original approach ( A* (B::*B_getA1)() = &B::getA; ) requires 
extra typing but provides a safety net for refactoring B::getA.



More information about the Cplusplus-sig mailing list