[IronPython] Auto conversion from list to array removed (sorry, formatting of previous message was faulty)

Jacques de Hooge jdehooge at fugro-jason.com
Thu Aug 3 18:10:52 CEST 2006



I've been moving my apps from IP 1 Beta 7 to IP 1 RC1.

I have not tested them completely, but I ran into the fact that automatic
conversion from list to array was removed.


If I remember right, the reason is that a C#  function receiving an array
param may alter it.

If a tuple is passed rather than an array, the user would not expect the
tuple to be altered.


- Is there a fundamental reason why the function could not update the
contents of the list offered to it?

- If not, couldn't some kind of optional ('strict' option) warning be
generated rather than prohibiting automatic conversion?

- Are you sure most Python programmers know enough about Python "passing
references by value" to be aware that the function could not replace the
tuple by a new instance (I tought some Python courses and my students,
originally coming from C++, are always baffled by that, even after multiple
years of Python experience)?



One of the places where I use automatic conversion is:


listViewItemsBuffer = []


for ... :

      listViewItemsBuffer.append (listViewItem)


listViewItems.AddRange (listViewItemsBuffer)



The alternatives are:



1. listViewItems.AddRange (tuple (listViewItemsBuffer))


Will probably create a third, redundant, copy of the long list of pointers
involved each time its called



2. listViewItems.AddRange (System.Array [Forms.ListViewItem]


Verbose (One of the things about Python programs is that they are much
shorter than their C# equivalents)



Well I guess you guys will have discussed this extensively.

Still I'd like to share the above thoughts with you.



Kind regards


J. de Hooge

info at geatec.com



-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mail.python.org/pipermail/ironpython-users/attachments/20060803/c26afe82/attachment.html>

More information about the Ironpython-users mailing list