[Mailman-Developers] Wiki Migration Update
paul at boddie.org.uk
Sun Nov 3 22:37:52 CET 2013
Time has passed and some more time has been spent on the wiki migration. As
always, the results can be found here:
The archived content now reflects the real wiki from yesterday - 2nd November
- so the translated content should reflect the existing wiki fairly accurately
and include recent edits.
Dates and History
One matter that was not addressed at all before now was that of accurate date
information in the page histories. I needed to patch the MoinMoin package
installer for this, and there turns out to be a good reason why it doesn't
support preserving the editing dates: the edit log would need sorting
afterwards, and that would probably need to be done offline. Moreover, taking
different packages of pages and combining them requires the histories from the
different packages to be merged, so I had to write a script to do this.
The result is that, subject to time zone ambiguity, the edit dates should be
accurate in the converted content and the RecentChanges should reflect what
you see on the current Confluence wiki.
Last time, I reintroduced user details to the migrated wiki, but one item that
remains is that of actually importing users. To illustrate user import, I
imported four recent users of the wiki that happened to be useful for testing
various aspects of the conversion. For example:
Here, you'll see that the comments at the bottom of the page bear the name of
the commenter, who helpfully supplied some non-ASCII characters in her name so
that I could encounter some problems with MoinMoin's command option handling.
As I mentioned last time, the method of acquiring user profile information is
not as satisfactory as that of getting the page data out of Confluence, but I
imagine that people will want to review the user list, exclude obvious
spammers, and then send out account reset e-mails - there must be some e-mail
experts here willing to do that nicely ;-) - and so the process will
necessarily involve some manual work.
Also done last time were redirects:
This time, I've added support for various other Confluence URL paths, such as
The special PDF export action is supported, although this really requires
Java, fop, xsltproc and DocBook XSL resources:
Confluence seems to use this kind of URL as well:
And there's also the highly sophisticated dashboard action (which just
redirects to the front page):
I have reviewed the import of comments and improved the functionality of the
MoinMoin extensions supporting new comments. I gave an example of comments
above in the "Users" section.
New comments assign complete ownership of a comment to the author, but that
author must have write access to the page on which the comment will appear
(even though they are actually making a subpage). Existing comments from
Confluence already assign ownership to the author of the comment when
I always provide a list of things that still need doing, so here are some
It might also be nice to have a list of attachments on pages that have them,
and I will take a look to see how Confluence tends to present such things.
(I'm not sure if this is a great priority, though. You can always follow the
"Attachments" link to see what's there.)
User home pages should probably be populated and have things like profile
images (if provided), activity indicators, and maybe the dashboard
functionality should be emulated, too. (People agreed that this wasn't a
As I have mentioned previously, the source code for the converter can be found
Please take another look at your favourite pages and let me know if anything
has gone badly wrong in the conversion process.
With this I hope we are nearing the point of final migration.
More information about the Mailman-Developers