[Numpy-discussion] Numarray 0.5

Peter Verveer verveer at embl-heidelberg.de
Wed May 7 02:17:12 EDT 2003

> > I am not sure if this is a bug, or intended behaviour, but the possibilty
> > to compare an array type object to 'Any' would be very useful for me.
> 'Any' grew up from the C-API,  rather than down from the Python design,
> so it's not very well thought out.  Right now,  it is a placeholder used
> to mark arrays with undefined types and to indicate "no type constraint"
> in C API calls.  In normal contexts,   you can't make an array of type
> 'Any'.  I think there are two reasonable behaviors for comparisons with
> 'Any',  both used in C.   The first behavior is literal comparison; here
> comparison to Any would generally return "not equal".  The second
> behavior is wild-card matching; here, comparison to Any would generally
> return "equal".   Which makes sense to you?  How do you want to use
> this?

I use 'Any' right now in C functions to indicate 'no type constraint'. You 
could use both literal comparison and wild-card matching behaviour for that, 
if you want to do this in Python, I think. But maybe one should not do such a 
thing in Python by comparison to 'Any' at all.

Literal comparison is what I generally expect from Python objects, so anything 
else may just be confusing (at least to me). However, the name 'Any' does 
suggest the wild-card matching behaviour. 

Is there specific reason why you exposed 'Any' in python? Maybe it would be 
better not to expose such a type object since it seems to be a 'special 
case'. I am starting to think that my use for it at the Python level is not 
appropiate. For instance, I could easily use 'None' instead, and I think I 
will do that in the future. 

You mentioned that 'Any' is really a C-API thing. Unless somebody has a good 
use for it I would now actually say that it maybe should not be exposed at 
the Python API level at all...

Cheers, Peter
Dr. Peter J. Verveer
Cell Biology and Cell Biophysics Programme
Meyerhofstrasse 1
D-69117 Heidelberg
Tel. : +49 6221 387245
Fax  : +49 6221 387242
Email: Peter.Verveer at embl-heidelberg.de

More information about the NumPy-Discussion mailing list