[pypy-commit] pypy default: Merge branch 'var-in-Some'

rlamy noreply at buildbot.pypy.org
Fri Oct 10 18:31:30 CEST 2014


Author: Ronan Lamy <ronan.lamy at gmail.com>
Branch: 
Changeset: r73889:46914a24fcd4
Date: 2014-10-10 17:30 +0100
http://bitbucket.org/pypy/pypy/changeset/46914a24fcd4/

Log:	Merge branch 'var-in-Some'

	Store annotations on the Variable objects, rather than in a big
	dict. Introduce a new framework for double-dispatched annotation
	implementations.

diff --git a/pypy/doc/whatsnew-head.rst b/pypy/doc/whatsnew-head.rst
--- a/pypy/doc/whatsnew-head.rst
+++ b/pypy/doc/whatsnew-head.rst
@@ -15,3 +15,7 @@
 
 .. branch: rtyper-stuff
 Small internal refactorings in the rtyper.
+
+.. branch: var-in-Some
+Store annotations on the Variable objects, rather than in a big dict.
+Introduce a new framework for double-dispatched annotation implementations.
diff --git a/rpython/annotator/annrpython.py b/rpython/annotator/annrpython.py
--- a/rpython/annotator/annrpython.py
+++ b/rpython/annotator/annrpython.py
@@ -17,7 +17,6 @@
 log = py.log.Producer("annrpython")
 py.log.setconsumer("annrpython", ansi_log)
 
-FAIL = object()
 
 class RPythonAnnotator(object):
     """Block annotator for RPython.
@@ -33,7 +32,6 @@
             translator.annotator = self
         self.translator = translator
         self.pendingblocks = {}  # map {block: graph-containing-it}
-        self.bindings = {}       # map Variables to SomeValues
         self.annotated = {}      # set of blocks already seen
         self.added_blocks = None # see processblock() below
         self.links_followed = {} # set of links that have ever been followed
@@ -54,7 +52,7 @@
         self.bookkeeper = bookkeeper
 
     def __getstate__(self):
-        attrs = """translator pendingblocks bindings annotated links_followed
+        attrs = """translator pendingblocks annotated links_followed
         notify bookkeeper frozen policy added_blocks""".split()
         ret = self.__dict__.copy()
         for key, value in ret.items():
@@ -143,7 +141,7 @@
         # recursively proceed until no more pending block is left
         if complete_now:
             self.complete()
-        return self.binding(flowgraph.getreturnvar(), None)
+        return self.annotation(flowgraph.getreturnvar())
 
     def gettype(self, variable):
         """Return the known type of a control flow graph variable,
@@ -151,9 +149,9 @@
         if isinstance(variable, Constant):
             return type(variable.value)
         elif isinstance(variable, Variable):
-            cell = self.bindings.get(variable)
-            if cell:
-                return cell.knowntype
+            s_variable = variable.annotation
+            if s_variable:
+                return s_variable.knowntype
             else:
                 return object
         else:
@@ -221,37 +219,39 @@
             raise annmodel.AnnotatorError(text)
         for graph in newgraphs:
             v = graph.getreturnvar()
-            if v not in self.bindings:
+            if v.annotation is None:
                 self.setbinding(v, annmodel.s_ImpossibleValue)
         # policy-dependent computation
         self.bookkeeper.compute_at_fixpoint()
 
-    def binding(self, arg, default=FAIL):
+    def annotation(self, arg):
         "Gives the SomeValue corresponding to the given Variable or Constant."
         if isinstance(arg, Variable):
-            try:
-                return self.bindings[arg]
-            except KeyError:
-                if default is not FAIL:
-                    return default
-                else:
-                    raise
+            return arg.annotation
         elif isinstance(arg, Constant):
             return self.bookkeeper.immutablevalue(arg.value)
         else:
             raise TypeError('Variable or Constant expected, got %r' % (arg,))
 
+    def binding(self, arg):
+        "Gives the SomeValue corresponding to the given Variable or Constant."
+        s_arg = self.annotation(arg)
+        if s_arg is None:
+            raise KeyError
+        return s_arg
+
     def typeannotation(self, t):
         return signature.annotation(t, self.bookkeeper)
 
     def setbinding(self, arg, s_value):
-        if arg in self.bindings:
-            assert s_value.contains(self.bindings[arg])
-        self.bindings[arg] = s_value
+        s_old = arg.annotation
+        if s_old is not None:
+            assert s_value.contains(s_old)
+        arg.annotation = s_value
 
     def transfer_binding(self, v_target, v_source):
-        assert v_source in self.bindings
-        self.bindings[v_target] = self.bindings[v_source]
+        assert v_source.annotation is not None
+        v_target.annotation = v_source.annotation
 
     def warning(self, msg, pos=None):
         if pos is None:
@@ -290,7 +290,7 @@
         # get the (current) return value
         v = graph.getreturnvar()
         try:
-            return self.bindings[v]
+            return self.binding(v)
         except KeyError:
             # the function didn't reach any return statement so far.
             # (some functions actually never do, they always raise exceptions)
@@ -328,7 +328,7 @@
         #  * block not in self.annotated:
         #      never seen the block.
         #  * self.annotated[block] == False:
-        #      the input variables of the block are in self.bindings but we
+        #      the input variables of the block have bindings but we
         #      still have to consider all the operations in the block.
         #  * self.annotated[block] == graph-containing-block:
         #      analysis done (at least until we find we must generalize the
@@ -443,7 +443,7 @@
             # is known
             exits = block.exits
             if isinstance(block.exitswitch, Variable):
-                s_exitswitch = self.bindings[block.exitswitch]
+                s_exitswitch = self.binding(block.exitswitch)
                 if s_exitswitch.is_constant():
                     exits = [link for link in exits
                                   if link.exitcase == s_exitswitch.const]
@@ -452,20 +452,7 @@
         # occour for this specific, typed operation.
         if block.exitswitch == c_last_exception:
             op = block.operations[-1]
-            if op.dispatch == 2:
-                arg1 = self.binding(op.args[0])
-                arg2 = self.binding(op.args[1])
-                binop = getattr(pair(arg1, arg2), op.opname, None)
-                can_only_throw = annmodel.read_can_only_throw(binop, arg1, arg2)
-            elif op.dispatch == 1:
-                arg1 = self.binding(op.args[0])
-                opname = op.opname
-                if opname == 'contains': opname = 'op_contains'
-                unop = getattr(arg1, opname, None)
-                can_only_throw = annmodel.read_can_only_throw(unop, arg1)
-            else:
-                can_only_throw = None
-
+            can_only_throw = op.get_can_only_throw(self)
             if can_only_throw is not None:
                 candidates = can_only_throw
                 candidate_exits = exits
@@ -482,8 +469,10 @@
 
         # mapping (exitcase, variable) -> s_annotation
         # that can be attached to booleans, exitswitches
-        knowntypedata = getattr(self.bindings.get(block.exitswitch),
-                                "knowntypedata", {})
+        knowntypedata = {}
+        if isinstance(block.exitswitch, Variable):
+            knowntypedata = getattr(self.binding(block.exitswitch),
+                                    "knowntypedata", {})
         for link in exits:
             self.follow_link(graph, link, knowntypedata)
         if block in self.notify:
@@ -578,22 +567,19 @@
         self.links_followed[link] = True
         self.addpendingblock(graph, link.target, cells)
 
-
     #___ creating the annotations based on operations ______
 
     def consider_op(self, op):
-        argcells = [self.binding(a) for a in op.args]
-
         # let's be careful about avoiding propagated SomeImpossibleValues
         # to enter an op; the latter can result in violations of the
         # more general results invariant: e.g. if SomeImpossibleValue enters is_
         #  is_(SomeImpossibleValue, None) -> SomeBool
         #  is_(SomeInstance(not None), None) -> SomeBool(const=False) ...
         # boom -- in the assert of setbinding()
-        for arg in argcells:
-            if isinstance(arg, annmodel.SomeImpossibleValue):
+        for arg in op.args:
+            if isinstance(self.annotation(arg), annmodel.SomeImpossibleValue):
                 raise BlockedInference(self, op, -1)
-        resultcell = op.consider(self, *argcells)
+        resultcell = op.consider(self, *op.args)
         if resultcell is None:
             resultcell = annmodel.s_ImpossibleValue
         elif resultcell == annmodel.s_ImpossibleValue:
diff --git a/rpython/annotator/binaryop.py b/rpython/annotator/binaryop.py
--- a/rpython/annotator/binaryop.py
+++ b/rpython/annotator/binaryop.py
@@ -13,7 +13,7 @@
     SomeLongFloat, SomeType, SomeConstantType, unionof, UnionError,
     read_can_only_throw, add_knowntypedata,
     merge_knowntypedata,)
-from rpython.annotator.bookkeeper import getbookkeeper, immutablevalue
+from rpython.annotator.bookkeeper import immutablevalue
 from rpython.flowspace.model import Variable, Constant
 from rpython.flowspace.operation import op
 from rpython.rlib import rarithmetic
@@ -23,6 +23,54 @@
                         if oper.dispatch == 2])
 
 
+ at op.is_.register(SomeObject, SomeObject)
+def is__default(annotator, obj1, obj2):
+    r = SomeBool()
+    s_obj1 = annotator.annotation(obj1)
+    s_obj2 = annotator.annotation(obj2)
+    if s_obj2.is_constant():
+        if s_obj1.is_constant():
+            r.const = s_obj1.const is s_obj2.const
+        if s_obj2.const is None and not s_obj1.can_be_none():
+            r.const = False
+    elif s_obj1.is_constant():
+        if s_obj1.const is None and not s_obj2.can_be_none():
+            r.const = False
+    knowntypedata = {}
+    bk = annotator.bookkeeper
+
+    def bind(src_obj, tgt_obj):
+        s_src = annotator.annotation(src_obj)
+        s_tgt = annotator.annotation(tgt_obj)
+        if hasattr(s_tgt, 'is_type_of') and s_src.is_constant():
+            add_knowntypedata(
+                knowntypedata, True,
+                s_tgt.is_type_of,
+                bk.valueoftype(s_src.const))
+        add_knowntypedata(knowntypedata, True, [tgt_obj], s_src)
+        s_nonnone = s_tgt
+        if (s_src.is_constant() and s_src.const is None and
+                s_tgt.can_be_none()):
+            s_nonnone = s_tgt.nonnoneify()
+        add_knowntypedata(knowntypedata, False, [tgt_obj], s_nonnone)
+
+    bind(obj2, obj1)
+    bind(obj1, obj2)
+    r.set_knowntypedata(knowntypedata)
+    return r
+
+def _make_cmp_annotator_default(cmp_op):
+    @cmp_op.register(SomeObject, SomeObject)
+    def default_annotate(annotator, obj1, obj2):
+        s_1, s_2 = annotator.annotation(obj1), annotator.annotation(obj2)
+        if s_1.is_immutable_constant() and s_2.is_immutable_constant():
+            return immutablevalue(cmp_op.pyfunc(s_1.const, s_2.const))
+        else:
+            return s_Bool
+
+for cmp_op in [op.lt, op.le, op.eq, op.ne, op.gt, op.ge]:
+    _make_cmp_annotator_default(cmp_op)
+
 class __extend__(pairtype(SomeObject, SomeObject)):
 
     def union((obj1, obj2)):
@@ -51,87 +99,12 @@
     inplace_floordiv.can_only_throw = [ZeroDivisionError]
     inplace_mod.can_only_throw = [ZeroDivisionError]
 
-    def lt((obj1, obj2)):
-        if obj1.is_immutable_constant() and obj2.is_immutable_constant():
-            return immutablevalue(obj1.const < obj2.const)
-        else:
-            return s_Bool
-
-    def le((obj1, obj2)):
-        if obj1.is_immutable_constant() and obj2.is_immutable_constant():
-            return immutablevalue(obj1.const <= obj2.const)
-        else:
-            return s_Bool
-
-    def eq((obj1, obj2)):
-        if obj1.is_immutable_constant() and obj2.is_immutable_constant():
-            return immutablevalue(obj1.const == obj2.const)
-        else:
-            return s_Bool
-
-    def ne((obj1, obj2)):
-        if obj1.is_immutable_constant() and obj2.is_immutable_constant():
-            return immutablevalue(obj1.const != obj2.const)
-        else:
-            return s_Bool
-
-    def gt((obj1, obj2)):
-        if obj1.is_immutable_constant() and obj2.is_immutable_constant():
-            return immutablevalue(obj1.const > obj2.const)
-        else:
-            return s_Bool
-
-    def ge((obj1, obj2)):
-        if obj1.is_immutable_constant() and obj2.is_immutable_constant():
-            return immutablevalue(obj1.const >= obj2.const)
-        else:
-            return s_Bool
-
     def cmp((obj1, obj2)):
         if obj1.is_immutable_constant() and obj2.is_immutable_constant():
             return immutablevalue(cmp(obj1.const, obj2.const))
         else:
             return SomeInteger()
 
-    def is_((obj1, obj2)):
-        r = SomeBool()
-        if obj2.is_constant():
-            if obj1.is_constant():
-                r.const = obj1.const is obj2.const
-            if obj2.const is None and not obj1.can_be_none():
-                r.const = False
-        elif obj1.is_constant():
-            if obj1.const is None and not obj2.can_be_none():
-                r.const = False
-        # XXX HACK HACK HACK
-        # XXX HACK HACK HACK
-        # XXX HACK HACK HACK
-        bk = getbookkeeper()
-        if bk is not None: # for testing
-            op = bk._find_current_op("is_", 2)
-            knowntypedata = {}
-            annotator = bk.annotator
-
-            def bind(src_obj, tgt_obj, tgt_arg):
-                if hasattr(tgt_obj, 'is_type_of') and src_obj.is_constant():
-                    add_knowntypedata(knowntypedata, True, tgt_obj.is_type_of,
-                                      bk.valueoftype(src_obj.const))
-
-                assert annotator.binding(op.args[tgt_arg]) == tgt_obj
-                add_knowntypedata(knowntypedata, True, [op.args[tgt_arg]], src_obj)
-
-                nonnone_obj = tgt_obj
-                if src_obj.is_constant() and src_obj.const is None and tgt_obj.can_be_none():
-                    nonnone_obj = tgt_obj.nonnoneify()
-
-                add_knowntypedata(knowntypedata, False, [op.args[tgt_arg]], nonnone_obj)
-
-            bind(obj2, obj1, 0)
-            bind(obj1, obj2, 1)
-            r.set_knowntypedata(knowntypedata)
-
-        return r
-
     def divmod((obj1, obj2)):
         return SomeTuple([pair(obj1, obj2).div(), pair(obj1, obj2).mod()])
 
@@ -271,10 +244,14 @@
             return SomeInteger(nonneg=int1.nonneg, knowntype=int1.knowntype)
     rshift.can_only_throw = []
 
-    def _compare_helper((int1, int2), opname, operation):
+
+def _make_cmp_annotator_int(cmp_op):
+    @cmp_op.register(SomeInteger, SomeInteger)
+    def _compare_helper(annotator, int1, int2):
         r = SomeBool()
-        if int1.is_immutable_constant() and int2.is_immutable_constant():
-            r.const = operation(int1.const, int2.const)
+        s_int1, s_int2 = annotator.annotation(int1), annotator.annotation(int2)
+        if s_int1.is_immutable_constant() and s_int2.is_immutable_constant():
+            r.const = cmp_op.pyfunc(s_int1.const, s_int2.const)
         #
         # The rest of the code propagates nonneg information between
         # the two arguments.
@@ -286,45 +263,38 @@
         # nonneg then "assert x>=y" will let the annotator know that
         # x is nonneg too, but it will not work if y is unsigned.
         #
-        if not (rarithmetic.signedtype(int1.knowntype) and
-                rarithmetic.signedtype(int2.knowntype)):
+        if not (rarithmetic.signedtype(s_int1.knowntype) and
+                rarithmetic.signedtype(s_int2.knowntype)):
             return r
         knowntypedata = {}
-        op = getbookkeeper()._find_current_op(opname=opname, arity=2)
-        def tointtype(int0):
-            if int0.knowntype is bool:
+        def tointtype(s_int0):
+            if s_int0.knowntype is bool:
                 return int
-            return int0.knowntype
-        if int1.nonneg and isinstance(op.args[1], Variable):
-            case = opname in ('lt', 'le', 'eq')
-
-            add_knowntypedata(knowntypedata, case, [op.args[1]],
-                              SomeInteger(nonneg=True, knowntype=tointtype(int2)))
-        if int2.nonneg and isinstance(op.args[0], Variable):
-            case = opname in ('gt', 'ge', 'eq')
-            add_knowntypedata(knowntypedata, case, [op.args[0]],
-                              SomeInteger(nonneg=True, knowntype=tointtype(int1)))
+            return s_int0.knowntype
+        if s_int1.nonneg and isinstance(int2, Variable):
+            case = cmp_op.opname in ('lt', 'le', 'eq')
+            add_knowntypedata(knowntypedata, case, [int2],
+                              SomeInteger(nonneg=True, knowntype=tointtype(s_int2)))
+        if s_int2.nonneg and isinstance(int1, Variable):
+            case = cmp_op.opname in ('gt', 'ge', 'eq')
+            add_knowntypedata(knowntypedata, case, [int1],
+                              SomeInteger(nonneg=True, knowntype=tointtype(s_int1)))
         r.set_knowntypedata(knowntypedata)
         # a special case for 'x < 0' or 'x >= 0',
         # where 0 is a flow graph Constant
         # (in this case we are sure that it cannot become a r_uint later)
-        if (isinstance(op.args[1], Constant) and
-            type(op.args[1].value) is int and    # filter out Symbolics
-            op.args[1].value == 0):
-            if int1.nonneg:
-                if opname == 'lt':
+        if (isinstance(int2, Constant) and
+                type(int2.value) is int and  # filter out Symbolics
+                int2.value == 0):
+            if s_int1.nonneg:
+                if cmp_op.opname == 'lt':
                     r.const = False
-                if opname == 'ge':
+                if cmp_op.opname == 'ge':
                     r.const = True
         return r
 
-    def lt(intint): return intint._compare_helper('lt', operator.lt)
-    def le(intint): return intint._compare_helper('le', operator.le)
-    def eq(intint): return intint._compare_helper('eq', operator.eq)
-    def ne(intint): return intint._compare_helper('ne', operator.ne)
-    def gt(intint): return intint._compare_helper('gt', operator.gt)
-    def ge(intint): return intint._compare_helper('ge', operator.ge)
-
+for cmp_op in [op.lt, op.le, op.eq, op.ne, op.gt, op.ge]:
+    _make_cmp_annotator_int(cmp_op)
 
 class __extend__(pairtype(SomeBool, SomeBool)):
 
@@ -746,25 +716,26 @@
         return SomeBuiltinMethod(bltn1.analyser, s_self,
                 methodname=bltn1.methodname)
 
+ at op.is_.register(SomePBC, SomePBC)
+def is__PBC_PBC(annotator, pbc1, pbc2):
+    s = is__default(annotator, pbc1, pbc2)
+    if not s.is_constant():
+        s_pbc1 = annotator.annotation(pbc1)
+        s_pbc2 = annotator.annotation(pbc2)
+        if not s_pbc1.can_be_None or not s_pbc2.can_be_None:
+            for desc in s_pbc1.descriptions:
+                if desc in s_pbc2.descriptions:
+                    break
+            else:
+                s.const = False    # no common desc in the two sets
+    return s
+
 class __extend__(pairtype(SomePBC, SomePBC)):
-
     def union((pbc1, pbc2)):
         d = pbc1.descriptions.copy()
         d.update(pbc2.descriptions)
         return SomePBC(d, can_be_None = pbc1.can_be_None or pbc2.can_be_None)
 
-    def is_((pbc1, pbc2)):
-        thistype = pairtype(SomePBC, SomePBC)
-        s = super(thistype, pair(pbc1, pbc2)).is_()
-        if not s.is_constant():
-            if not pbc1.can_be_None or not pbc2.can_be_None:
-                for desc in pbc1.descriptions:
-                    if desc in pbc2.descriptions:
-                        break
-                else:
-                    s.const = False    # no common desc in the two sets
-        return s
-
 class __extend__(pairtype(SomeImpossibleValue, SomeObject)):
     def union((imp1, obj2)):
         return obj2
diff --git a/rpython/annotator/bookkeeper.py b/rpython/annotator/bookkeeper.py
--- a/rpython/annotator/bookkeeper.py
+++ b/rpython/annotator/bookkeeper.py
@@ -89,14 +89,14 @@
                 newblocks = self.annotator.added_blocks
                 if newblocks is None:
                     newblocks = self.annotator.annotated  # all of them
-                binding = self.annotator.binding
+                annotation = self.annotator.annotation
                 for block in newblocks:
                     for op in block.operations:
                         if op.opname in ('simple_call', 'call_args'):
                             yield op
 
                         # some blocks are partially annotated
-                        if binding(op.result, None) is None:
+                        if annotation(op.result) is None:
                             break   # ignore the unannotated part
 
             for call_op in call_sites():
@@ -144,15 +144,17 @@
 
     def consider_call_site(self, call_op):
         from rpython.rtyper.llannotation import SomeLLADTMeth, lltype_to_annotation
-        binding = self.annotator.binding
-        s_callable = binding(call_op.args[0])
-        args_s = [binding(arg) for arg in call_op.args[1:]]
+        annotation = self.annotator.annotation
+        s_callable = annotation(call_op.args[0])
+        args_s = [annotation(arg) for arg in call_op.args[1:]]
         if isinstance(s_callable, SomeLLADTMeth):
             adtmeth = s_callable
             s_callable = self.immutablevalue(adtmeth.func)
             args_s = [lltype_to_annotation(adtmeth.ll_ptrtype)] + args_s
         if isinstance(s_callable, SomePBC):
-            s_result = binding(call_op.result, s_ImpossibleValue)
+            s_result = annotation(call_op.result)
+            if s_result is None:
+                s_result = s_ImpossibleValue
             args = call_op.build_args(args_s)
             self.consider_call_site_for_pbc(s_callable, args,
                                             s_result, call_op)
@@ -500,8 +502,9 @@
             # needed by some kinds of specialization.
             fn, block, i = self.position_key
             op = block.operations[i]
-            s_previous_result = self.annotator.binding(op.result,
-                                                       s_ImpossibleValue)
+            s_previous_result = self.annotator.annotation(op.result)
+            if s_previous_result is None:
+                s_previous_result = s_ImpossibleValue
         else:
             if emulated is True:
                 whence = None
diff --git a/rpython/annotator/test/test_annrpython.py b/rpython/annotator/test/test_annrpython.py
--- a/rpython/annotator/test/test_annrpython.py
+++ b/rpython/annotator/test/test_annrpython.py
@@ -857,7 +857,11 @@
         s = a.build_types(snippet.harmonic, [int])
         assert s.knowntype == float
         # check that the list produced by range() is not mutated or resized
-        for s_value in a.bindings.values():
+        graph = graphof(a, snippet.harmonic)
+        all_vars = set().union(*[block.getvariables() for block in graph.iterblocks()])
+        print all_vars
+        for var in all_vars:
+            s_value = var.annotation
             if isinstance(s_value, annmodel.SomeList):
                 assert not s_value.listdef.listitem.resized
                 assert not s_value.listdef.listitem.mutated
@@ -2767,8 +2771,8 @@
         a = self.RPythonAnnotator()
         a.build_types(f, [])
         v1, v2 = graphof(a, readout).getargs()
-        assert not a.bindings[v1].is_constant()
-        assert not a.bindings[v2].is_constant()
+        assert not a.binding(v1).is_constant()
+        assert not a.binding(v2).is_constant()
 
     def test_prebuilt_mutables_dont_use_eq(self):
         # test that __eq__ is not called during annotation, at least
diff --git a/rpython/annotator/test/test_model.py b/rpython/annotator/test/test_model.py
--- a/rpython/annotator/test/test_model.py
+++ b/rpython/annotator/test/test_model.py
@@ -20,25 +20,6 @@
 class C(object):
     pass
 
-class DummyClassDef:
-    def __init__(self, cls=C):
-        self.cls = cls
-        self.name = cls.__name__
-
-si0 = SomeInstance(DummyClassDef(), True)
-si1 = SomeInstance(DummyClassDef())
-sTrue = SomeBool()
-sTrue.const = True
-sFalse = SomeBool()
-sFalse.const = False
-
-def test_is_None():
-    assert pair(s_None, s_None).is_() == sTrue
-    assert pair(si1, s_None).is_() == sFalse
-    assert pair(si0, s_None).is_() != sTrue
-    assert pair(si0, s_None).is_() != sFalse
-    assert pair(si0, s_None).is_() == SomeBool()
-
 def test_equality():
     assert s1 != s2 != s3 != s4 != s5 != s6
     assert s1 == SomeType()
diff --git a/rpython/annotator/unaryop.py b/rpython/annotator/unaryop.py
--- a/rpython/annotator/unaryop.py
+++ b/rpython/annotator/unaryop.py
@@ -19,19 +19,41 @@
 
 UNARY_OPERATIONS = set([oper.opname for oper in op.__dict__.values()
                         if oper.dispatch == 1])
+UNARY_OPERATIONS.remove('contains')
 
+ at op.type.register(SomeObject)
+def type_SomeObject(annotator, arg):
+    r = SomeType()
+    r.is_type_of = [arg]
+    return r
+
+ at op.bool.register(SomeObject)
+def bool_SomeObject(annotator, obj):
+    r = SomeBool()
+    annotator.annotation(obj).bool_behavior(r)
+    s_nonnone_obj = annotator.annotation(obj)
+    if s_nonnone_obj.can_be_none():
+        s_nonnone_obj = s_nonnone_obj.nonnoneify()
+    knowntypedata = {}
+    add_knowntypedata(knowntypedata, True, [obj], s_nonnone_obj)
+    r.set_knowntypedata(knowntypedata)
+    return r
+
+ at op.contains.register(SomeObject)
+def contains_SomeObject(annotator, obj, element):
+    return s_Bool
+contains_SomeObject.can_only_throw = []
+
+ at op.simple_call.register(SomeObject)
+def simple_call_SomeObject(annotator, func, *args):
+    return annotator.annotation(func).call(simple_args([annotator.annotation(arg) for arg in args]))
+
+ at op.call_args.register(SomeObject)
+def call_args(annotator, func, *args):
+    return annotator.annotation(func).call(complex_args([annotator.annotation(arg) for arg in args]))
 
 class __extend__(SomeObject):
 
-    def type(self, *moreargs):
-        if moreargs:
-            raise Exception('type() called with more than one argument')
-        r = SomeType()
-        bk = getbookkeeper()
-        op = bk._find_current_op(opname="type", arity=1, pos=0, s_type=self)
-        r.is_type_of = [op.args[0]]
-        return r
-
     def issubtype(self, s_cls):
         if hasattr(self, 'is_type_of'):
             vars = self.is_type_of
@@ -53,21 +75,6 @@
             if s_len.is_immutable_constant():
                 s.const = s_len.const > 0
 
-    def bool(s_obj):
-        r = SomeBool()
-        s_obj.bool_behavior(r)
-
-        bk = getbookkeeper()
-        knowntypedata = {}
-        op = bk._find_current_op(opname="bool", arity=1)
-        arg = op.args[0]
-        s_nonnone_obj = s_obj
-        if s_obj.can_be_none():
-            s_nonnone_obj = s_obj.nonnoneify()
-        add_knowntypedata(knowntypedata, True, [arg], s_nonnone_obj)
-        r.set_knowntypedata(knowntypedata)
-        return r
-
     def hash(self):
         raise AnnotatorError("cannot use hash() in RPython")
 
@@ -133,19 +140,9 @@
     def bind_callables_under(self, classdef, name):
         return self   # default unbound __get__ implementation
 
-    def simple_call(self, *args_s):
-        return self.call(simple_args(args_s))
-
-    def call_args(self, *args_s):
-        return self.call(complex_args(args_s))
-
     def call(self, args, implicit_init=False):
         raise AnnotatorError("Cannot prove that the object is callable")
 
-    def op_contains(self, s_element):
-        return s_Bool
-    op_contains.can_only_throw = []
-
     def hint(self, *args_s):
         return self
 
@@ -249,6 +246,12 @@
         items = self.items[s_start.const:s_stop.const]
         return SomeTuple(items)
 
+ at op.contains.register(SomeList)
+def contains_SomeList(annotator, obj, element):
+    annotator.annotation(obj).listdef.generalize(annotator.annotation(element))
+    return s_Bool
+contains_SomeList.can_only_throw = []
+
 
 class __extend__(SomeList):
 
@@ -296,11 +299,6 @@
     def getanyitem(self):
         return self.listdef.read_item()
 
-    def op_contains(self, s_element):
-        self.listdef.generalize(s_element)
-        return s_Bool
-    op_contains.can_only_throw = []
-
     def hint(self, *args_s):
         hints = args_s[-1].const
         if 'maxlength' in hints:
@@ -340,6 +338,21 @@
         raise AnnotatorError("%s: not proven to have non-negative stop" % error)
 
 
+def _can_only_throw(s_dct, *ignore):
+    if s_dct.dictdef.dictkey.custom_eq_hash:
+        return None    # r_dict: can throw anything
+    return []          # else: no possible exception
+
+ at op.contains.register(SomeDict)
+def contains_SomeDict(annotator, dct, element):
+    annotator.annotation(dct).dictdef.generalize_key(annotator.annotation(element))
+    if annotator.annotation(dct)._is_empty():
+        s_bool = SomeBool()
+        s_bool.const = False
+        return s_bool
+    return s_Bool
+contains_SomeDict.can_only_throw = _can_only_throw
+
 class __extend__(SomeDict):
 
     def _is_empty(self):
@@ -421,19 +434,19 @@
             self.dictdef.generalize_value(s_dfl)
         return self.dictdef.read_value()
 
-    def _can_only_throw(self, *ignore):
-        if self.dictdef.dictkey.custom_eq_hash:
-            return None    # r_dict: can throw anything
-        return []          # else: no possible exception
-
-    def op_contains(self, s_element):
-        self.dictdef.generalize_key(s_element)
-        if self._is_empty():
-            s_bool = SomeBool()
-            s_bool.const = False
-            return s_bool
-        return s_Bool
-    op_contains.can_only_throw = _can_only_throw
+ at op.contains.register(SomeString)
+ at op.contains.register(SomeUnicodeString)
+def contains_String(annotator, string, char):
+    if annotator.annotation(char).is_constant() and annotator.annotation(char).const == "\0":
+        r = SomeBool()
+        knowntypedata = {}
+        add_knowntypedata(knowntypedata, False, [string],
+                          annotator.annotation(string).nonnulify())
+        r.set_knowntypedata(knowntypedata)
+        return r
+    else:
+        return contains_SomeObject(annotator, string, char)
+contains_String.can_only_throw = []
 
 
 class __extend__(SomeString,
@@ -508,19 +521,6 @@
         result = self.basestringclass(no_nul=self.no_nul)
         return result
 
-    def op_contains(self, s_element):
-        if s_element.is_constant() and s_element.const == "\0":
-            r = SomeBool()
-            bk = getbookkeeper()
-            op = bk._find_current_op(opname="contains", arity=2, pos=0, s_type=self)
-            knowntypedata = {}
-            add_knowntypedata(knowntypedata, False, [op.args[0]], self.nonnulify())
-            r.set_knowntypedata(knowntypedata)
-            return r
-        else:
-            return SomeObject.op_contains(self, s_element)
-    op_contains.can_only_throw = []
-
     def method_format(self, *args):
         raise AnnotatorError("Method format() is not RPython")
 
@@ -709,9 +709,6 @@
         return self._emulate_call('__setslice__', s_start, s_stop, s_iterable)
 
 class __extend__(SomeBuiltin):
-    def simple_call(self, *args):
-        return self.analyser(*args)
-
     def call(self, args, implicit_init=False):
         args_s, kwds = args.unpack()
         # prefix keyword arguments with 's_'
diff --git a/rpython/flowspace/model.py b/rpython/flowspace/model.py
--- a/rpython/flowspace/model.py
+++ b/rpython/flowspace/model.py
@@ -10,29 +10,6 @@
 from rpython.tool.sourcetools import PY_IDENTIFIER, nice_repr_for_func
 
 
-"""
-    memory size before and after introduction of __slots__
-    using targetpypymain with -no-c
-
-    slottified          annotation  ann+genc
-    -------------------------------------------
-    nothing             321 MB      442 MB
-    Var/Const/SpaceOp   205 MB      325 MB
-    + Link              189 MB      311 MB
-    + Block             185 MB      304 MB
-
-    Dropping Variable.instances and using
-    just an instancenames dict brought
-    annotation down to 160 MB.
-    Computing the Variable.renamed attribute
-    and dropping Variable.instancenames
-    got annotation down to 109 MB.
-    Probably an effect of less fragmentation.
-"""
-
-__metaclass__ = type
-
-
 class FunctionGraph(object):
     def __init__(self, name, startblock, return_var=None):
         self.name = name  # function name (possibly mangled already)
@@ -273,7 +250,7 @@
 
 
 class Variable(object):
-    __slots__ = ["_name", "_nr", "concretetype"]
+    __slots__ = ["_name", "_nr", "annotation", "concretetype"]
 
     dummyname = 'v'
     namesdict = {dummyname: (dummyname, 0)}
@@ -296,6 +273,7 @@
     def __init__(self, name=None):
         self._name = self.dummyname
         self._nr = -1
+        self.annotation = None
         # numbers are bound lazily, when the name is requested
         if name is not None:
             self.rename(name)
@@ -334,6 +312,15 @@
     def foldable(self):
         return False
 
+    def copy(self):
+        """Make a copy of the Variable, preserving annotations and concretetype."""
+        newvar = Variable(self)
+        newvar.annotation = self.annotation
+        if hasattr(self, 'concretetype'):
+            newvar.concretetype = self.concretetype
+        return newvar
+
+
 
 class Constant(Hashable):
     __slots__ = ["concretetype"]
diff --git a/rpython/flowspace/operation.py b/rpython/flowspace/operation.py
--- a/rpython/flowspace/operation.py
+++ b/rpython/flowspace/operation.py
@@ -7,13 +7,14 @@
 import operator
 import sys
 import types
-from rpython.tool.pairtype import pair
+from rpython.tool.pairtype import pair, DoubleDispatchRegistry
 from rpython.rlib.unroll import unrolling_iterable, _unroller
 from rpython.tool.sourcetools import compile2
 from rpython.flowspace.model import (Constant, WrapException, const, Variable,
                                      SpaceOperation)
 from rpython.flowspace.specialcase import register_flow_sc
-from rpython.annotator.model import SomeTuple
+from rpython.annotator.model import (
+    SomeTuple, AnnotatorError, read_can_only_throw)
 from rpython.annotator.argument import ArgumentsForTranslation
 from rpython.flowspace.specialcase import SPECIAL_CASES
 
@@ -54,6 +55,11 @@
         type.__init__(cls, name, bases, attrdict)
         if hasattr(cls, 'opname'):
             setattr(op, cls.opname, cls)
+        if cls.dispatch == 1:
+            cls._registry = {}
+        elif cls.dispatch == 2:
+            cls._registry = DoubleDispatchRegistry()
+
 
 class HLOperation(SpaceOperation):
     __metaclass__ = HLOperationMeta
@@ -90,11 +96,13 @@
     def constfold(self):
         return None
 
-    def consider(self, annotator, *argcells):
-        consider_meth = getattr(annotator, 'consider_op_' + self.opname, None)
-        if not consider_meth:
-            raise Exception("unknown op: %r" % op)
-        return consider_meth(*argcells)
+    def consider(self, annotator, *args):
+        args_s = [annotator.annotation(arg) for arg in args]
+        spec = type(self).get_specialization(*args_s)
+        return spec(annotator, *args)
+
+    def get_can_only_throw(self, annotator):
+        return None
 
 class PureOperation(HLOperation):
     pure = True
@@ -141,16 +149,72 @@
 class SingleDispatchMixin(object):
     dispatch = 1
 
-    def consider(self, annotator, arg, *other_args):
-        impl = getattr(arg, self.opname)
-        return impl(*other_args)
+    @classmethod
+    def register(cls, Some_cls):
+        def decorator(func):
+            cls._registry[Some_cls] = func
+            return func
+        return decorator
+
+    @classmethod
+    def _dispatch(cls, Some_cls):
+        for c in Some_cls.__mro__:
+            try:
+                return cls._registry[c]
+            except KeyError:
+                pass
+        raise AnnotatorError("Unknown operation")
+
+    def get_can_only_throw(self, annotator):
+        args_s = [annotator.annotation(v) for v in self.args]
+        spec = type(self).get_specialization(*args_s)
+        return read_can_only_throw(spec, args_s[0])
+
+    @classmethod
+    def get_specialization(cls, s_arg, *_ignored):
+        try:
+            impl = getattr(s_arg, cls.opname)
+
+            def specialized(annotator, arg, *other_args):
+                return impl(*[annotator.annotation(x) for x in other_args])
+            try:
+                specialized.can_only_throw = impl.can_only_throw
+            except AttributeError:
+                pass
+            return specialized
+        except AttributeError:
+            return cls._dispatch(type(s_arg))
+
 
 class DoubleDispatchMixin(object):
     dispatch = 2
 
-    def consider(self, annotator, arg1, arg2, *other_args):
-        impl = getattr(pair(arg1, arg2), self.opname)
-        return impl(*other_args)
+    @classmethod
+    def register(cls, Some1, Some2):
+        def decorator(func):
+            cls._registry[Some1, Some2] = func
+            return func
+        return decorator
+
+    @classmethod
+    def get_specialization(cls, s_arg1, s_arg2, *_ignored):
+        try:
+            impl = getattr(pair(s_arg1, s_arg2), cls.opname)
+
+            def specialized(annotator, arg1, arg2, *other_args):
+                return impl(*[annotator.annotation(x) for x in other_args])
+            try:
+                specialized.can_only_throw = impl.can_only_throw
+            except AttributeError:
+                pass
+            return specialized
+        except AttributeError:
+            return cls._registry[type(s_arg1), type(s_arg2)]
+
+    def get_can_only_throw(self, annotator):
+        args_s = [annotator.annotation(v) for v in self.args]
+        spec = type(self).get_specialization(*args_s)
+        return read_can_only_throw(spec, args_s[0], args_s[1])
 
 
 def add_operator(name, arity, dispatch=None, pyfunc=None, pure=False, ovf=False):
@@ -368,14 +432,15 @@
 add_operator('newslice', 3)
 add_operator('hint', None, dispatch=1)
 
-class Contains(PureOperation):
+class Contains(SingleDispatchMixin, PureOperation):
     opname = 'contains'
     arity = 2
     pyfunc = staticmethod(operator.contains)
 
-    # XXX "contains" clash with SomeObject method
-    def consider(self, annotator, seq, elem):
-        return seq.op_contains(elem)
+    # XXX "contains" clashes with SomeObject method
+    @classmethod
+    def get_specialization(cls, s_seq, s_elem):
+        return cls._dispatch(type(s_seq))
 
 
 class NewDict(HLOperation):
@@ -392,7 +457,7 @@
     canraise = []
 
     def consider(self, annotator, *args):
-        return SomeTuple(items=args)
+        return SomeTuple(items=[annotator.annotation(arg) for arg in args])
 
 
 class NewList(HLOperation):
@@ -400,7 +465,7 @@
     canraise = []
 
     def consider(self, annotator, *args):
-        return annotator.bookkeeper.newlist(*args)
+        return annotator.bookkeeper.newlist(*[annotator.annotation(arg) for arg in args])
 
 
 class Pow(PureOperation):
diff --git a/rpython/memory/gctransform/asmgcroot.py b/rpython/memory/gctransform/asmgcroot.py
--- a/rpython/memory/gctransform/asmgcroot.py
+++ b/rpython/memory/gctransform/asmgcroot.py
@@ -10,7 +10,7 @@
      BaseFrameworkGCTransformer, BaseRootWalker)
 from rpython.rtyper.llannotation import SomeAddress
 from rpython.rtyper.rbuiltin import gen_cast
-from rpython.translator.unsimplify import copyvar, varoftype
+from rpython.translator.unsimplify import varoftype
 from rpython.translator.tool.cbuild import ExternalCompilationInfo
 import sys
 
@@ -140,7 +140,7 @@
         block1 = Block([])
         reloadedvars = []
         for v, c_p in zip(block2.inputargs, sra):
-            v = copyvar(None, v)
+            v = v.copy()
             if isinstance(v.concretetype, lltype.Ptr):
                 w = varoftype(llmemory.Address)
             else:
diff --git a/rpython/rlib/test/test_signature.py b/rpython/rlib/test/test_signature.py
--- a/rpython/rlib/test/test_signature.py
+++ b/rpython/rlib/test/test_signature.py
@@ -19,7 +19,7 @@
 def sigof(a, f):
     # returns [param1, param2, ..., ret]
     g = graphof(a.translator, f)
-    return [a.bindings[v] for v in g.startblock.inputargs] + [a.bindings[g.getreturnvar()]]
+    return [a.binding(v) for v in g.startblock.inputargs] + [a.binding(g.getreturnvar())]
 
 def getsig(f, policy=None):
     a = annotate_at(f, policy=policy)
diff --git a/rpython/rtyper/callparse.py b/rpython/rtyper/callparse.py
--- a/rpython/rtyper/callparse.py
+++ b/rpython/rtyper/callparse.py
@@ -19,7 +19,7 @@
 
 def getrresult(rtyper, graph):
     """Return the repr of the result variable of the 'graph'."""
-    if graph.getreturnvar() in rtyper.annotator.bindings:
+    if graph.getreturnvar().annotation is not None:
         return rtyper.bindingrepr(graph.getreturnvar())
     else:
         return lltype.Void
diff --git a/rpython/rtyper/rtyper.py b/rpython/rtyper/rtyper.py
--- a/rpython/rtyper/rtyper.py
+++ b/rpython/rtyper/rtyper.py
@@ -17,7 +17,6 @@
 
 from rpython.annotator import model as annmodel, unaryop, binaryop
 from rpython.rtyper.llannotation import SomePtr, lltype_to_annotation
-from rpython.annotator.annrpython import FAIL
 from rpython.flowspace.model import Variable, Constant, SpaceOperation, c_last_exception
 from rpython.rtyper.annlowlevel import annotate_lowlevel_helper, LowLevelAnnotatorPolicy
 from rpython.rtyper.error import TyperError
@@ -152,8 +151,12 @@
         assert result is not None     # recursive getrepr()!
         return result
 
-    def binding(self, var, default=FAIL):
-        s_obj = self.annotator.binding(var, default)
+    def annotation(self, var):
+        s_obj = self.annotator.annotation(var)
+        return s_obj
+
+    def binding(self, var):
+        s_obj = self.annotator.binding(var)
         return s_obj
 
     def bindingrepr(self, var):
@@ -493,7 +496,7 @@
                     hop.r_result, op.opname, resulttype))
             # figure out if the resultvar is a completely fresh Variable or not
             if (isinstance(resultvar, Variable) and
-                resultvar not in self.annotator.bindings and
+                resultvar.annotation is None and
                 resultvar not in varmapping):
                 # fresh Variable: rename it to the previously existing op.result
                 varmapping[resultvar] = op.result
@@ -635,7 +638,7 @@
             ARG_GCSTRUCT = GCSTRUCT
         args_s = [SomePtr(Ptr(ARG_GCSTRUCT))]
         graph = self.annotate_helper(func, args_s)
-        s = self.annotator.binding(graph.getreturnvar())
+        s = self.annotation(graph.getreturnvar())
         if (not isinstance(s, SomePtr) or
             s.ll_ptrtype != Ptr(RuntimeTypeInfo)):
             raise TyperError("runtime type info function %r returns %r, "
@@ -882,7 +885,9 @@
         newargs_v = []
         for v in args_v:
             if v.concretetype is Void:
-                s_value = rtyper.binding(v, default=annmodel.s_None)
+                s_value = rtyper.annotation(v)
+                if s_value is None:
+                    s_value = annmodel.s_None
                 if not s_value.is_constant():
                     raise TyperError("non-constant variable of type Void")
                 if not isinstance(s_value, (annmodel.SomePBC, annmodel.SomeNone)):
diff --git a/rpython/tool/error.py b/rpython/tool/error.py
--- a/rpython/tool/error.py
+++ b/rpython/tool/error.py
@@ -106,7 +106,7 @@
 def format_simple_call(annotator, oper, msg):
     msg.append("Occurred processing the following simple_call:")
     try:
-        descs = annotator.bindings[oper.args[0]].descriptions
+        descs = annotator.binding(oper.args[0]).descriptions
     except (KeyError, AttributeError), e:
         msg.append("      (%s getting at the binding!)" % (
             e.__class__.__name__,))
diff --git a/rpython/tool/pairtype.py b/rpython/tool/pairtype.py
--- a/rpython/tool/pairtype.py
+++ b/rpython/tool/pairtype.py
@@ -61,3 +61,36 @@
         bases = tuple(bases1 + bases2) or (tuple,)  # 'tuple': ultimate base
         pair = pairtypecache[cls1, cls2] = extendabletype(name, bases, {})
     return pair
+
+def pairmro(cls1, cls2):
+    """
+    Return the resolution order on pairs of types for double dispatch.
+
+    This order is compatible with the mro of pairtype(cls1, cls2).
+    """
+    for base2 in cls2.__mro__:
+        for base1 in cls1.__mro__:
+            yield (base1, base2)
+
+class DoubleDispatchRegistry(object):
+    """
+    A mapping of pairs of types to arbitrary objects respecting inheritance
+    """
+    def __init__(self):
+        self._registry = {}
+        self._cache = {}
+
+    def __getitem__(self, clspair):
+        try:
+            return self._cache[clspair]
+        except KeyError:
+            cls1, cls2 = clspair
+            for c1, c2 in pairmro(cls1, cls2):
+                if (c1, c2) in self._cache:
+                    return self._cache[(c1, c2)]
+            else:
+                raise
+
+    def __setitem__(self, clspair, value):
+        self._registry[clspair] = value
+        self._cache = self._registry.copy()
diff --git a/rpython/tool/test/test_pairtype.py b/rpython/tool/test/test_pairtype.py
--- a/rpython/tool/test/test_pairtype.py
+++ b/rpython/tool/test/test_pairtype.py
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
+from rpython.tool.pairtype import (
+    pairtype, pair, extendabletype, pairmro, DoubleDispatchRegistry)
 
-from rpython.tool.pairtype import pairtype, pair, extendabletype
-
-def test_binop(): 
+def test_binop():
     ### Binary operation example
     class __extend__(pairtype(int, int)):
         def add((x, y)):
@@ -13,16 +13,16 @@
         def add((x, y)):
             return 'bool: %s+%s' % (x, y)
 
-    assert pair(3,4).add() == 'integer: 3+4'
-    assert pair(3,4).sub() == 'integer: 3-4'
-    assert pair(3,True).add() == 'integer: 3+True'
-    assert pair(3,True).sub() == 'integer: 3-True'
-    assert pair(False,4).add() == 'integer: False+4'
-    assert pair(False,4).sub() == 'integer: False-4'
-    assert pair(False,True).add() == 'bool: False+True'
-    assert pair(False,True).sub() == 'integer: False-True'
+    assert pair(3, 4).add() == 'integer: 3+4'
+    assert pair(3, 4).sub() == 'integer: 3-4'
+    assert pair(3, True).add() == 'integer: 3+True'
+    assert pair(3, True).sub() == 'integer: 3-True'
+    assert pair(False, 4).add() == 'integer: False+4'
+    assert pair(False, 4).sub() == 'integer: False-4'
+    assert pair(False, True).add() == 'bool: False+True'
+    assert pair(False, True).sub() == 'integer: False-True'
 
-def test_somebuiltin(): 
+def test_somebuiltin():
     ### Operation on built-in types
     class MiniPickler:
         def __init__(self):
@@ -48,7 +48,7 @@
     pair(p, [1, 2, ['hello', 3]]).write()
     assert p.data == ['I1', 'I2', 'Shello', 'I3', 'L2', 'L3']
 
-def test_some_multimethod(): 
+def test_some_multimethod():
     ### Another multimethod example
     class Block:
         def __init__(self, exit):
@@ -57,7 +57,7 @@
         pass
     class Switch:
         pass
-    
+
     class C_Generator:
         def __init__(self):
             self.lines = []
@@ -78,7 +78,7 @@
 
     g = C_Generator()
     pair(g, Block(Switch())).emit(['v1', 'v2'])
-    assert g.lines == ["C code for block", "switch (v5) { ... }"] 
+    assert g.lines == ["C code for block", "switch (v5) { ... }"]
 
     class Lisp_Generator:
         def __init__(self):
@@ -95,16 +95,37 @@
 def test_multiple_extend():
     class A:
         __metaclass__ = extendabletype
+
     class B:
         __metaclass__ = extendabletype
 
-    class __extend__(A,B):
-
+    class __extend__(A, B):
         def f(self):
             pass
 
     assert hasattr(A, 'f')
     assert hasattr(B, 'f')
-    
 
-        
+def test_pairmro():
+    class A(object): pass
+    class A2(A): pass
+    class A3(A2): pass
+    class B(object): pass
+    class B2(B): pass
+    parent_pairtypes = pairtype(A3, B2).__mro__[:-2]
+    assert (tuple(pairtype(a, b) for a, b in pairmro(A3, B2)) == parent_pairtypes)
+
+def test_doubledispatch():
+    class A(object): pass
+    class A2(A): pass
+    class A3(A2): pass
+    class B(object): pass
+    class B2(B): pass
+    reg = DoubleDispatchRegistry()
+    reg[object, object] = "default"
+    assert reg[A3, B2] == "default"
+    reg[A2, B2] = "A2-B2"
+    assert reg[A, B2] == "default"
+    assert reg[A3, B2] == "A2-B2"
+    reg[A3, B] = "A3-B"
+    assert reg[A3, B2] == "A2-B2"  # note that A2,B2 wins over A3,B
diff --git a/rpython/translator/backendopt/inline.py b/rpython/translator/backendopt/inline.py
--- a/rpython/translator/backendopt/inline.py
+++ b/rpython/translator/backendopt/inline.py
@@ -8,7 +8,7 @@
 from rpython.translator.backendopt.canraise import RaiseAnalyzer
 from rpython.translator.backendopt.support import log, find_loop_blocks
 from rpython.translator.simplify import join_blocks, cleanup_graph, get_graph
-from rpython.translator.unsimplify import copyvar, split_block
+from rpython.translator.unsimplify import split_block
 
 
 class CannotInline(Exception):
@@ -236,14 +236,13 @@
         if isinstance(var, Constant):
             return var
         if var not in self.varmap:
-            self.varmap[var] = copyvar(None, var)
+            self.varmap[var] = var.copy()
         return self.varmap[var]
 
     def passon_vars(self, cache_key):
         if cache_key in self._passon_vars:
             return self._passon_vars[cache_key]
-        result = [copyvar(None, var)
-                      for var in self.original_passon_vars]
+        result = [var.copy() for var in self.original_passon_vars]
         self._passon_vars[cache_key] = result
         return result
 
@@ -362,8 +361,8 @@
         exc_match.concretetype = typeOf(exc_match.value)
         blocks = []
         for i, link in enumerate(afterblock.exits[1:]):
-            etype = copyvar(None, copiedexceptblock.inputargs[0])
-            evalue = copyvar(None, copiedexceptblock.inputargs[1])
+            etype = copiedexceptblock.inputargs[0].copy()
+            evalue = copiedexceptblock.inputargs[1].copy()
             passon_vars = self.passon_vars(i)
             block = Block([etype, evalue] + passon_vars)
             res = Variable()
diff --git a/rpython/translator/backendopt/ssa.py b/rpython/translator/backendopt/ssa.py
--- a/rpython/translator/backendopt/ssa.py
+++ b/rpython/translator/backendopt/ssa.py
@@ -158,8 +158,6 @@
     'graph_or_blocks' can be a graph, or just a dict that lists some blocks
     from a graph, as follows: {block: reachable-from-outside-flag}.
     """
-    from rpython.translator.unsimplify import copyvar
-
     entrymap = mkinsideentrymap(graph_or_blocks)
     builder = DataFlowFamilyBuilder(graph_or_blocks)
     variable_families = builder.get_variable_families()
@@ -203,7 +201,7 @@
             except KeyError:
                 raise Exception("SSA_to_SSI failed: no way to give a value to"
                                 " %r in %r" % (v, block))
-            w = copyvar(annotator, v)
+            w = v.copy()
             variable_families.union(v, w)
             block.renamevariables({v: w})
             block.inputargs.append(w)
diff --git a/rpython/translator/exceptiontransform.py b/rpython/translator/exceptiontransform.py
--- a/rpython/translator/exceptiontransform.py
+++ b/rpython/translator/exceptiontransform.py
@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
 from rpython.translator.simplify import join_blocks, cleanup_graph
-from rpython.translator.unsimplify import copyvar, varoftype
+from rpython.translator.unsimplify import varoftype
 from rpython.translator.unsimplify import insert_empty_block, split_block
 from rpython.translator.backendopt import canraise, inline
 from rpython.flowspace.model import Block, Constant, Variable, Link, \
@@ -305,8 +305,7 @@
         reraise = self.comes_from_last_exception(entrymap, link)
         result = Variable()
         result.concretetype = lltype.Void
-        block = Block([copyvar(None, v)
-                       for v in graph.exceptblock.inputargs])
+        block = Block([v.copy() for v in graph.exceptblock.inputargs])
         if reraise:
             block.operations = [
                 SpaceOperation("direct_call",
@@ -345,7 +344,7 @@
         inlined, the correct exception matching blocks are produced."""
         # XXX slightly annoying: construct a graph by hand
         # but better than the alternative
-        result = copyvar(None, op.result)
+        result = op.result.copy()
         opargs = []
         inputargs = []
         callargs = []
@@ -435,7 +434,7 @@
                 result_i = l0.args.index(v_result)
                 v_result_after = normalafterblock.inputargs[result_i]
             else:
-                v_result_after = copyvar(None, v_result)
+                v_result_after = v_result.copy()
                 l0.args.append(v_result)
                 normalafterblock.inputargs.append(v_result_after)
             if true_zero:
diff --git a/rpython/translator/goal/query.py b/rpython/translator/goal/query.py
--- a/rpython/translator/goal/query.py
+++ b/rpython/translator/goal/query.py
@@ -33,7 +33,7 @@
         try:
             for block in g.iterblocks():
                 for v in block.getvariables():
-                    s = annotator.binding(v, None)
+                    s = annotator.annotation(v)
                     if s and s.__class__ == annmodel.SomeObject and s.knowntype != type:
                         raise Found
         except Found:
@@ -44,8 +44,8 @@
     annotator = translator.annotator
     for graph in translator.graphs:
         et, ev = graph.exceptblock.inputargs
-        s_et = annotator.binding(et, None)
-        s_ev = annotator.binding(ev, None)
+        s_et = annotator.annotation(et)
+        s_ev = annotator.annotation(ev)
         if s_et:
             if s_et.knowntype == type:
                 if s_et.__class__ == annmodel.SomeType:
diff --git a/rpython/translator/tool/graphpage.py b/rpython/translator/tool/graphpage.py
--- a/rpython/translator/tool/graphpage.py
+++ b/rpython/translator/tool/graphpage.py
@@ -106,12 +106,6 @@
         self.source = make_dot_graphs(name, gs, target=None)
         # make the dictionary of links -- one per annotated variable
         self.current_value = {}
-        if self.annotator:
-            for var, s_value in self.annotator.bindings.items():
-                info = '%s: %s' % (var.name, s_value)
-                annotationcolor = getattr(s_value, 'annotationcolor', None)
-                self.links[var.name] = info, annotationcolor
-                self.current_value[var.name] = s_value
 
         #from rpython.jit.hintannotator.annotator import HintAnnotator
         #if isinstance(self.annotator, HintAnnotator):
@@ -128,6 +122,12 @@
                     for v in link.getextravars():
                         vars[v] = True
         for var in vars:
+            s_value = var.annotation
+            if s_value is not None:
+                info = '%s: %s' % (var.name, s_value)
+                annotationcolor = getattr(s_value, 'annotationcolor', None)
+                self.links[var.name] = info, annotationcolor
+                self.current_value[var.name] = s_value
             if hasattr(var, 'concretetype'):
                 #info = self.links.get(var.name, var.name)
                 #info = '(%s) %s' % (var.concretetype, info)
diff --git a/rpython/translator/transform.py b/rpython/translator/transform.py
--- a/rpython/translator/transform.py
+++ b/rpython/translator/transform.py
@@ -89,8 +89,8 @@
         for i in range(len(block.operations)):
             op = block.operations[i]
             if op.opname == 'mul':
-                s0 = self.binding(op.args[0], None)
-                s1 = self.binding(op.args[1], None)
+                s0 = self.annotation(op.args[0])
+                s1 = self.annotation(op.args[1])
                 if (isinstance(s0, annmodel.SomeChar) and
                     isinstance(s1, annmodel.SomeInteger)):
                     mul_sources[op.result] = op.args[0], op.args[1]
@@ -124,14 +124,14 @@
             elif op.opname == 'contains' and op.args[0] in newlist_sources:
                 items = {}
                 for v in newlist_sources[op.args[0]]:
-                    s = self.binding(v)
+                    s = self.annotation(v)
                     if not s.is_immutable_constant():
                         break
                     items[s.const] = None
                 else:
                     # all arguments of the newlist are annotation constants
                     op.args[0] = Constant(items)
-                    s_dict = self.binding(op.args[0])
+                    s_dict = self.annotation(op.args[0])
                     s_dict.dictdef.generalize_key(self.binding(op.args[1]))
 
 
@@ -168,9 +168,9 @@
     "Fix a block whose end can never be reached at run-time."
     # search the operation that cannot succeed
     can_succeed    = [op for op in block.operations
-                         if op.result in self.bindings]
+                         if op.result.annotation is not None]
     cannot_succeed = [op for op in block.operations
-                         if op.result not in self.bindings]
+                         if op.result.annotation is None]
     n = len(can_succeed)
     # check consistency
     assert can_succeed == block.operations[:n]
@@ -178,8 +178,7 @@
     assert 0 <= n < len(block.operations)
     # chop off the unreachable end of the block
     del block.operations[n+1:]
-    s_impossible = annmodel.SomeImpossibleValue()
-    self.bindings[block.operations[n].result] = s_impossible
+    self.setbinding(block.operations[n].result, annmodel.s_ImpossibleValue)
     # insert the equivalent of 'raise AssertionError'
     graph = self.annotated[block]
     msg = "Call to %r should have raised an exception" % (getattr(graph, 'func', None),)
diff --git a/rpython/translator/unsimplify.py b/rpython/translator/unsimplify.py
--- a/rpython/translator/unsimplify.py
+++ b/rpython/translator/unsimplify.py
@@ -2,16 +2,6 @@
     SpaceOperation, c_last_exception, checkgraph)
 
 
-def copyvar(annotator, v):
-    """Make a copy of the Variable v, preserving annotations and concretetype."""
-    assert isinstance(v, Variable)
-    newvar = Variable(v)
-    if annotator is not None and v in annotator.bindings:
-        annotator.transfer_binding(newvar, v)
-    if hasattr(v, 'concretetype'):
-        newvar.concretetype = v.concretetype
-    return newvar
-
 def varoftype(concretetype, name=None):
     var = Variable(name)
     var.concretetype = concretetype
@@ -31,7 +21,7 @@
     vars = [v for v, keep in vars.items() if keep]
     mapping = {}
     for v in vars:
-        mapping[v] = copyvar(annotator, v)
+        mapping[v] = v.copy()
     newblock = Block(vars)
     newblock.operations.extend(newops)
     newblock.closeblock(Link(link.args, link.target))
@@ -41,7 +31,7 @@
     return newblock
 
 def insert_empty_startblock(annotator, graph):
-    vars = [copyvar(annotator, v) for v in graph.startblock.inputargs]
+    vars = [v.copy() for v in graph.startblock.inputargs]
     newblock = Block(vars)
     newblock.closeblock(Link(vars, graph.startblock))
     graph.startblock = newblock
@@ -72,7 +62,7 @@
         if var in vars_produced_in_new_block:
             return var
         if var not in varmap:
-            varmap[var] = copyvar(annotator, var)
+            varmap[var] = var.copy()
         return varmap[var]
     moved_operations = block.operations[index:]
     new_moved_ops = []
@@ -146,7 +136,7 @@
         annhelper.finish()
 
     entry_point = translator.entry_point_graph
-    args = [copyvar(translator.annotator, v) for v in entry_point.getargs()]
+    args = [v.copy() for v in entry_point.getargs()]
     extrablock = Block(args)
     v_none = varoftype(lltype.Void)
     newop = SpaceOperation('direct_call', [c_initial_func], v_none)
@@ -169,7 +159,7 @@
         annhelper.finish()
 
     entry_point = translator.entry_point_graph
-    v = copyvar(translator.annotator, entry_point.getreturnvar())
+    v = entry_point.getreturnvar().copy()
     extrablock = Block([v])
     v_none = varoftype(lltype.Void)
     newop = SpaceOperation('direct_call', [c_final_func], v_none)


More information about the pypy-commit mailing list