[pypy-dev] security prototype & workshop plans/ideas
hpk at trillke.net
Thu Apr 13 15:38:39 CEST 2006
from the EU side of things there is the plan to organize a
security workshop and implement security features within PyPy.
I now talked to my IBM research lab contact in Zuerich,
and we discussed a few possibilities for such a workshop
and the prototype, in particular two possibilities:
- data tagging or "label control", or more generally attaching
(security) metainformations to a python object and having those
propagate through the program automatically. See e.g.
for some more information in this direction. This is especially
interesting for PyPy as - i think - we can probably do better
by e.g. also allowing to tag primitive types (JFlow doesn't
do that, i think) and allowing things to happen more dynamically
- sandboxing: allowing to execute (user-supplied/induced)
code and preventing it from accessing critical resources,
e.g. system IO.
Label control could be used for tagging e.g. user-level input
with the "untrusted" label and then protecting certain
functions to require trusted input (e.g. database/file modifications).
Then, there could be explicit untrusted_to_trusted()
conversions, turning an untrusted input into a trusted
output. This would allow to concisely localise how
user-supplied/untrusted input is parsed and checked.
I also guess we could also go for a more general
metadata-tagging approach which might be useful in more than
just the security context.
This are just initial ideas - there are arbitrary other
possibilities (somewhere care to discuss the "E" lang here?),
or are there not? :)
The challenge is to find an interesting mechanism that
elegantly enables such approaches - which should be the
topic of our upcoming security prototype and workshop.
Sandboxing and/or e.g. limiting RAM/CPU usage are also
interesting to the Python world but probably are
a rather orthogonal matter.
Regarding the timing of the workshop it seems that something
like October this year fits best. It depends on our actual
plan and availability/selection of workshop participants if
we rather should try to meet in Zuerich or in New York.
We can also try to first arrange a discussion with them
and then a meeting for presenting the results but that
may be a bit much for us (we are not really lacking
challenges currently :).
I am posting here on pypy-dev (rather than just to selected pypy
developers) because others may be interested, have comments,
suggestions or might think about contributing. Security is
certainly not the central topic of PyPy but our design should
make it considerably easier to implement strong security features.
Hum, and i guess that it's not impossible that the project
might for contributors come up with funding for travels at
More information about the Pypy-dev