[pypy-dev] [pypy-svn] r33528 - in pypy/dist/pypy/translator: jvm jvm/src jvm/test oosupport

Carl Friedrich Bolz cfbolz at gmx.de
Mon Oct 23 11:59:00 CEST 2006


Maciek Fijalkowski wrote:
> Niko Matsakis wrote:
> 
>>> As well as some of your commits have broken JS tests. I'm not totally
>>> convinced that my attempt (returning void) is better than your (not
>>> returning void), but please at least run JS tests and check if nothing
>>> is broken. If you brake something, but you're totally convinced  that 
>>> I'm
>>> the one who should fix something please at least contact me, I  would be
>>> happy to sort things out.
>>
>> My sincere apologies!  I was trying to be careful not to break  
>> things, but evidently not careful enough.  I will make sure to run  
>> the JS tests in the future --- I didn't in the past because I assumed  
>> I did not have the required software.
>>
>> Regarding the change to get_ and set_field to make it ignore Void  
>> arguments, I ported that from the CLI code --- I mentioned it on IRC  
>> and people thought it was a good idea.  I don't really understand too  
>> well whether it is necessary or not, but I am afraid that your change  
>> might break the CLI tests, as previously they relied upon their own  
>> version of the GetField MetaVM op which *did* ignore the Void  
>> operations.
>>
>> Again, my apologies for breaking things. :)

I think it happened to everybody at one point.


> Sorry for being too agressive :-] Actually I do agree with you and I'll 
> make JS working that way. Just please inform me each time you change 
> something which breaks tests explicitely.

Well, actually your fix broke the cli tests :-).

Cheers,

Carl Friedrich



More information about the Pypy-dev mailing list