[issue14629] discrepency between tokenize.detect_encoding() and PyTokenizer_FindEncodingFilename()

Eric Snow report at bugs.python.org
Fri Apr 20 07:17:18 CEST 2012

New submission from Eric Snow <ericsnowcurrently at gmail.com>:

(see http://mail.python.org/pipermail/python-dev/2012-April/118889.html)

The behavior of tokenize.detect_encoding() and PyTokenizer_FindEncodingFilename() is unexpectedly different and this has bearing on the current work on imports.

When a file has no encoding indicator (see PEP 263) it falls back to UTF8 (see PEP 3120).  The tokenize module (Lib/tokenize.py) facilitates this through "detect_encoding()".  The CPython internal tokenizer (Python/tokenizer.c) does so through "PyTokenizer_FindEncodingFilename()".  Both check the first two lines of the file, per PEP 263.

When faced with an unparsable file (per the encoding), tokenize.detect_encoding() will gladly give you the encoding without any fuss.  However, PyTokenizer_FindEncodingFilename() will raise a SyntaxError in that situation.

The 'badsyntax_pep3120' test (Lib/test/badsyntax_pep3120.py) is one module that demonstrates this discrepency.  I'll use it in the following example.


For tokenize.detect_encoding():

  import tokenize
  enc = tokenize.detect_encoding(open("cpython/Lib/test/badsyntax_pep3120.py").readline)
  print(enc)  # "utf-8" (no SyntaxError)

For PyTokenizer_FindEncodingFilename():

I've attached the source for a C extension module ('_tokenizer') that wraps PyTokenizer_FindEncodingFilename().

  import _tokenizer
  enc = _tokenizer.detect_encoding("cpython/Lib/test/badsyntax_pep3120.py")
  print(enc)  # raises SyntaxError


Some relevant, related notes:

The discrepencies extend further too.  The following code returns a UnicodeDecodeError, rather than a SyntaxError:


In 3.1 (C-based import machinery, Python/import.c), the following results in a SyntaxError, during encoding detection.  In the current repo tip (importlib-based import machinery, Lib/importlib/_bootstrap.py), the following results in a SyntaxError much later, during compilation.

  import test.badsyntax_pep3120

importlib uses tokenize.detect_encoding() and import.c uses PyTokenizer_FindEncodingFilename()...

components: Library (Lib)
files: _tokenizer.c
messages: 158797
nosy: brett.cannon, eric.snow, loewis
priority: normal
severity: normal
status: open
title: discrepency between tokenize.detect_encoding() and PyTokenizer_FindEncodingFilename()
type: behavior
versions: Python 3.3
Added file: http://bugs.python.org/file25283/_tokenizer.c

Python tracker <report at bugs.python.org>

More information about the Python-bugs-list mailing list