[issue14191] argparse: nargs='*' doesn't get out-of-order positional parameters

[Steven Bethard]

Steven Bethard <steven.bethard at gmail.com> added the comment:

> Hence, I conclude that, unless this was spelled out in the PEP and I 
> missed it, that having such boundaries is a bug

Practically speaking, we just can't change this because it will break existing argparse scripts. Argparse has had this behavior since 2006 when it was first released, and I guarantee you that many scripts expect and rely on this behavior.

As I said earlier, the only reasonable solution is to document the current behavior more explicitly, and then add a new constructor parameter or method or something to enable the behavior you want.

I looked a bit a guilherme's patch, and I think it's not really the right direction. We definitely shouldn't be modifying the action classes like _StoreAction. All changes should be within _parse_known_args. The parsing algorithm is so different for the proposed behavior, that I wonder if it wouldn't be easier to just create a new ArgumentParser subclass, ArgumentParserAllowingOptionalsInsidePositionals (or whatever), that just overrides _parse_known_args and rewrites it entirely.

----------

_______________________________________
Python tracker <report at bugs.python.org>
<http://bugs.python.org/issue14191>
_______________________________________