[issue16669] Docstrings for namedtuple

Ned Batchelder report at bugs.python.org
Sun Dec 8 17:41:49 CET 2013


Ned Batchelder added the comment:

I'll add my voice to those asking for a way to put docstrings on namedtuples.  As it is, namedtuples get automatic docstrings that seem to me to be almost worse than none.  Sphinx produces this:

```
class Key

    Key(scope, user_id, block_scope_id, field_name)

    __getnewargs__()

        Return self as a plain tuple. Used by copy and pickle.

    __repr__()

        Return a nicely formatted representation string

    block_scope_id None

        Alias for field number 2

    field_name None

        Alias for field number 3

    scope None

        Alias for field number 0

    user_id None

        Alias for field number 1
```

Why are `__getnewargs__` and `__repr__` included at all, they aren't useful for API documentation.  The individual property docstrings offer no new information over the summary at the top.   I'd like namedtuple not to be so verbose where it has no useful information to offer.  The one-line summary is all the information namedtuple has, so that is all it should include in the docstring:

```
class Key

    Key(scope, user_id, block_scope_id, field_name)
```

----------
nosy: +nedbat

_______________________________________
Python tracker <report at bugs.python.org>
<http://bugs.python.org/issue16669>
_______________________________________


More information about the Python-bugs-list mailing list