[Python-Dev] datetime module enhancements

[Jon Ribbens]

Brett Cannon <brett at python.org> wrote:
> > Treat dates as if they have a time-part of midnight. This is my preferred
> > solution, and it is already what the datetime module does, for example,
> > when subtracting two dates.
> 
> I personally like the current solution.  The proposal to just assume
> midnight goes against EIBTI in my mind.

Not in mine. The comparison of a date with a datetime throwing
an exception is astonishing in my mind.

The problem is, if you don't define a 'date' as I suggest (i.e.
midnight at the start of the day in question), then what *does*
a 'date' represent?

If you want the answer to be "an unknown time on that day" then
you need to alter the datetime module so that subtracting one
date from another throws an exception.

If you want the answer to be "the entire of that day" then you need
to alter the datetime module so that, e.g. subtracting 2007-03-08
from 2007-03-09 does not return "one day" as currently, but returns
"zero days" instead (since of course there is no time between the end
of one day and the start of the next day).

Obviously both of those alternatives are ludicrous (not to mention
they would break backwards-compatibility), so I would suggest the
only logical solution is to make the change I proposed ;-)