[Python-Dev] [Python-checkins] cpython (3.3): Issue #16045: add more unit tests for built-in int()

[Terry Reedy]

> +    # For example, PyPy 1.9.0 raised TypeError for these cases because it
> +    # expects x to be a string if base is given.
> +    @support.cpython_only
> +    def test_base_arg_with_no_x_arg(self):
> +        self.assertEquals(int(base=6), 0)
> +        # Even invalid bases don't raise an exception.
> +        self.assertEquals(int(base=1), 0)
> +        self.assertEquals(int(base=1000), 0)
> +        self.assertEquals(int(base='foo'), 0)

I think the above behavior is buggy and should be changed rather than 
frozen into CPython with a test. According to the docs, PyPy does it right.

The current online doc gives the signature as
int(x=0)
int(x, base=10) <<where x is s string>>

The 3.3.0 docstring says
"When converting a string, use the optional base.  It is an error to 
supply a base when converting a non-string."

Certainly, accepting any object as a base, violating "The allowed values 
are 0 and 2-36." just because giving a base is itself invalid is crazy.

--
Terry Jan Reedy