[Python-Dev] Bytes path support
antoine at python.org
Wed Aug 20 15:01:40 CEST 2014
Le 20/08/2014 07:08, Nick Coghlan a écrit :
> It's not just the JVM that says text and binary APIs should be separate
> - it's every widely used operating system services layer except POSIX.
> The POSIX way works well *if* everyone reliably encodes things as UTF-8
> or always uses encoding detection, but its failure mode is unfortunately
> silent data corruption.
> That said, there's a lot of Python software that is POSIX specific,
> where bytes paths would be the least of the barriers to porting to
> Windows or Jython. I'm personally +1 on consistently allowing binary
> paths in lower level APIs, but disallowing them in higher level
> explicitly cross platform abstractions like pathlib.
I fully agree with Nick's position here.
To elaborate specifically about pathlib, it doesn't handle bytes paths
but allows you to generate them if desired:
Adding full bytes support to pathlib would have added a lot of
complication and fragility in the implementation *and* in the API (is it
allowed to combine str and bytes paths? should they have separate
classes?), for arguably little benefit.
I think if you want low-level features (such as unconverted bytes paths
under POSIX), it is reasonable to point you to low-level APIs.
More information about the Python-Dev