[Python-ideas] [Python-Dev] yield * (Re: Missing operator.call)
steve at pearwood.info
Sun Feb 8 23:20:48 CET 2009
Antoine Pitrou wrote:
> Steven D'Aprano <steve at ...> writes:
>> The advantage is even more obvious when married with a generator expression:
>> yield from (3*x for x in seq if x%2 == 1)
>> instead of:
>> for x in seq:
>> if x%2 == 1:
>> yield 3*x
> But the former will be slower than the latter, because it constructs an
> intermediate generator only to yield it element by element.
The "yield from" syntax hasn't even been approved, let alone
implemented, and you're already complaining it's slow? Talk about
That's a criticism of *generator expressions*, not the suggested syntax.
They're popular because most people prefer the large benefits in
readability and convenience over the minuscule cost in generating them,
particularly since often that cost is paid somewhere else: the caller
builds the generator expression and passes the resulting iterator into
your function, which merely iterates over it.
And the cost is small:
[steve at ando ~]$ python -m timeit -s "seq = range(500)" "(3*x for x in
seq if x%2 == 1)"
1000000 loops, best of 3: 0.611 usec per loop
More information about the Python-ideas