A Modest Proposal -- <wink>

Patrick Phalen python-list at teleo.net
Sat Nov 13 17:47:37 CET 1999


[Magnus L. Hetland, on Sat, 13 Nov 1999]:

:: But - if you have XPPMS, why do you need XWTSNTSDL? You could just
:: transform
:: 
::    This is some text <wink>
:: 
:: into
:: 
::    <wink>This is some text</wink>
:: 
:: and Bob's your uncle... Then you can use standard XML tools... :)


I am against this notion, for several reasons. 

1. XPPMS should disavow any attempt to do anything useful. I thought we
had all agreed to this. It's in the spec!

2. It gratuitously introduces containment and well-formedness, which,
in turn, threatens several key objectives of XWTSNTSDL, XGNBAML, and
XACL, namely:

* Make XML software significantly harder to write
* Make source files significantly harder to read

We must be especially cautious not to introduce any changes at
this point which might make XML easier to teach to beginners.





More information about the Python-list mailing list