Python 1.6 alpha 1 released
arnold at dstc.edu.au
Tue Apr 4 08:45:57 EDT 2000
-->"Terry" == Terry Reedy <tjreedy at udel.edu> writes:
Terry> Without countervailing philosophical justification, this
Terry> code-breaking change strikes me as contrary to both the
Terry> spirit and practice of python.
the justification is (and always was) that connect() does not always
take a host and port. it *does* always take a single address
parameter. the format of that address parameter depends on the
address/protocol family with which the socket was created.
Terry> If the connect() code currently also accepts the new form,
Terry> then the API could be tightened just as well by eliminating
Terry> the one-tuple variant. How much code would that break?
(just to be pedantic, it's not the new form. it's the form from as
long as i can remember -- 1.1? 1.3 at least)
maintaining the current hack to support two arguments is probably the
best solution, given the storm of protest this has caused. i don't
know why Guido proposed its removal, but perhaps it's not worth it?
More information about the Python-list