Why aren't colons optional?
grante at visi.com
Sun Jan 20 11:58:17 EST 2002
In article <3C4AAA46.BC5D570E at tds.net>, Edward K. Ream wrote:
>> Why are colons required after def, elif, else, except, finally, for, if,
>> try and while? One would think the colon would be optional when the
>> colon is followed by a newline.
> Thanks to all who replied. To summarize the responses: This is not a
> parser issue; apparently Guido believes colons increase readability.
IIRC, there were actual studies conducted with one of the
precursor languages (ABC?) which determined that the colon
increased readability -- at least for new programmers.
> Also, making trailing colons optional would impact many tools.
> I am unconvinced, and I'm not going to press the issue.
Perhaps if you ask, somebody can provide a cite?
Grant Edwards grante Yow! Let's send the
at Russians defective
visi.com lifestyle accessories!
More information about the Python-list