[2.3] object does not appear to be a reserved word

Mike C. Fletcher mcfletch at rogers.com
Sat Sep 6 22:10:13 CEST 2003


John Roth wrote:

>"Daniel Klein" <danielk at aracnet.com> wrote in message
>news:v89klvsupdoe39e6trqbbqvmhfgecnoum8 at 4ax.com...
>  
>
>>Is it potentially dangerous to use the variable 'object' in code?
>>    
>>
>
>"object" is, I believe, a built-in type in the builtins namespace.
>As such,  you can shadow it so it's inacessable. However,
>the only place were that could cause problems is if you
>use it as an identifier at the module level. I think.
>  
>
Another place: errors in (copied) code which get silently ignored 
because of the presence of the "object" type. 

For instance, if you cut-and-past a few lines of (older, particularly 
pre-2.2) code which uses the variable "object" into a new situation 
which uses "item" (or whatever), the older code will often seem to be 
functioning properly because it uses the type "object" as an instance, 
instead of raising a NameError.  Tends to result in subtle bugs, but not 
likely enough to warrant breaking all the old code that used "object" as 
an identifier by making it a keyword.

To answer the original question, yes, it's somewhat dangerous to use 
"object" as an identifier in code.  It's approximately equally dangerous 
to use "str", "list", or "tuple" as an identifier.  It's just that the 
temptation to use "object" is greater when you're doing a lot of 
polymorphic programming, and you'll find older code (pre 2.2) using it 
without any concern whatsoever (because there was no object type back 
then to cause a problem). 

Each new built-in causes the same problem, it's just that "object" is so 
fundamental an idea (both as a built-in and an identifer) that it's 
probably the most likely source of such low-level conflicts going 
forward.  (e.g. enumerate, or zip are used in code once in a while, but 
compared to "object" are fairly uncommon choices for an identifier).

Enjoy,
Mike

_______________________________________
  Mike C. Fletcher
  Designer, VR Plumber, Coder
  http://members.rogers.com/mcfletch/








More information about the Python-list mailing list