a question on __slots__ (and example from Nutshell)

Ixokai usenet at ixokai.net
Thu Jun 3 00:41:09 CEST 2004

The problem is that the __slots__ mechanism is a function of "new style
classes", which really should be renamed =) A new-style-class is any class
that inherits from "object" or one of its descendants.

You're inheriting from Rectangle. What is its definition? I bet its
something like:

    class Rectangle:
        def __init__(self): pass

Since OptimizedRectangle inherits from an old-style class, its an old-style
class... and  __slots__ has no function.

So, just...

    class Rectangle(object): pass

And OptimizedRectangle should work like you expect.


"Porky Pig Jr" <porky_pig_jr at my-deja.com> wrote in message
news:56cfb0e3.0406021358.3d50d921 at posting.google.com...
> Hello, I"m still learning Python, but going through the Ch 5 OOP of
> Nutshell book. There is discussion on __slots__, and my understanding
> from reading this section is that if I have a class Rectangle (as
> defined in some prior sections), and then I provide definition
> class OptimizedRectangle(Rectangle):
>      __slots__ = 'width', 'heigth'
> I can use the instance of OptimizedRectangle, say, x, with 'width' and
> 'heigth', but (quoting the book) 'any attempt to bind on x any
> attribute whose name is not in C.__slots__ raises an exception.
> Alas, something goes wrong here, but I *can* bind any arbitrary
> attribute, and seems like the instance of OptimizedRectangle does have
> its own __dict__ where those attributes are kept. I'm using the latest
> stable version of Python (2.3.4, I believe). Here is a session from
> Here I'm defining the class with __slots__:
> >>> class OptimizedRectangle(Rectangle):
> __slots__ = 'width', 'heigth'
> and create its instance, 'ropt':
> >>> ropt = OptimizedRectangle(4,5)
> Note that __dict__ is still there:
> >>> ropt.__dict__
> {}
> so I can define some arbitrary variable, say, newarea:
> >>> ropt.newarea = 15
> which goes into the dictionary
> >>> ropt.__dict__
> {'newarea': 15}
> whereas width and heigth are still kept in __slots__:
> >>> ropt.__slots__
> ('width', 'heigth')
> My impression is that once __slots__ are defined, __dict__ is
> effectively disabled - but in this example it's alive and well. Am I
> missing anything here?
> TIA.

More information about the Python-list mailing list