XML and namespaces
alanmk at hotmail.com
Wed Dec 7 16:58:42 CET 2005
> It's libxml2 that does all the work, and the libxml2
> authors claim that libxml2 implements the DOM level 2 document model,
> but with a different API.
That statement is meaningless.
The DOM is *only* an API, i.e. an interface. The opening statement on
the W3C DOM page is
What is the Document Object Model?
The Document Object Model is a platform- and language-neutral interface
that will allow programs and scripts to dynamically access and update
the content, structure and style of documents.
The interfaces that make up the different levels of the DOM are
described in CORBA IDL - Interface Definition Language.
DOM Implementations are free to implement the methods and properties of
the IDL interfaces as they see fit. Some implementations might maintain
an object model, with separate objects for each node in the tree,
several string variables associated with each node, i.e. node name,
namespace, etc. But they could just as easily store those data in
tables, indexed by some node id. (As an aside, the non-DOM-compatible
Xalan Table Model does exactly that:
So when the libxml2 developers say (copied from http://www.xmlsoft.org/)
To some extent libxml2 provides support for the following additional
specifications but doesn't claim to implement them completely:
* Document Object Model (DOM)
http://www.w3.org/TR/DOM-Level-2-Core/ the document model, but it
doesn't implement the API itself, gdome2 does this on top of libxml2
They've completely missed the point: DOM is *only* the API.
> Maybe they're wrong, but wasn't the whole point of this subthread that
> different developers have interpreted the specification in different ways ?
What specification? Libxml2 implements none of the DOM specifications.
email alan: http://xhaus.com/contact/alan
More information about the Python-list