Random image text generation?

Steven D'Aprano steve at REMOVE.THIS.cybersource.com.au
Sun Nov 12 23:33:06 CET 2006


On Sun, 12 Nov 2006 14:56:49 -0600, skip wrote:

> 
>     >> Is there a module out there that will generate an image with a random
>     >> text string such as the confirmation images you see on various
>     >> websites?
> 
>     Mitja> They're called captcha images or captchas for short.  Googling
>     Mitja> for "python captcha" returns several hits; see what you like...
> 
> Thanks.  I'd never heard that term before.  Assuming I can get PIL installed
> with freetype support on my Mac the ASPN recipe looks like it will do the
> trick.

Keep in mind two serious problems with captchas:

- they're impossible for the blind or people using text-only browsers to
see -- even mere colour blindness can make some captchas impossible to
solve;

- sometimes they're too difficult for even those with perfect vision to
decipher.


Two alternatives:

Instead of displaying an obfuscated image of a nonsense word, display six
randomly chosen photos, where five are of the same thing but not the same
image. E.g. you might show five different kittens and a horse. The user
has to click on the image that is not the same as the others.
State-of-the-art horse-recognition software is not yet in widespread use
by spammers *wink*

For a text only solution, consider putting up a natural language question
such as:

What is the third letter of 'national'?
What is four plus two?
How many eggs in a dozen?
Fill in the blank: Mary had a little ____ its fleece was white as snow.
Cat, Dog, Apple, Bird. One of those words is a fruit. Which one?

Beware of making the questions too difficult or too specific:

In the third season of Babylon Five, what did Mr Morden ask Lando? 

Also, keep in mind that all captchas are vulnerable to the old
distributed hybrid human-machine network trick: "We'll give you a free
account on our porn site if you spend fifteen minutes a day solving
captchas for our bot network." The only solution to that, I fear, is open
season on spammers and anyone who buys from a spammer.



-- 
Steven.




More information about the Python-list mailing list