Picking a license

[Lawrence D'Oliveiro]

In message <mailman.141.1273767256.32709.python-list at python.org>, Ed Keith 
wrote:

> Assertion I:
>    If person A is free to do more than person B, then person A has
>    more freedom then person B.
> 
> Assertion II:
>    If person A is free do perform an action person B is not free to
>    perform then person A is free to do more than person B.
> 
> Assertion III:
>   If person B is restricted in some way that person A is not them Person A
>   is free to do something Person B is not free to do.
> 
> Conclusion:
>   If person B is more resticted than Peston A, Person A has mor freedom
>   than person B.
> 
> Which step in this reasoning do you disagree with?

Under the GPL, everybody has exactly the same freedoms. So which of your 
assertions is supposedly a criticism of the GPL?