Dynamic imports + relative imports in Python 3

zildjohn01 john at superfreakingawesome.com
Tue Feb 22 18:24:15 CET 2011


This is a copy-paste of a StackOverflow question. Nobody answered
there, but I figured I might have better luck here.

I have a Python 3 project where I'm dynamically importing modules from
disk, using `imp.load_module`. But, I've run into an problem where
relative imports fail, when the relative import occurs within a
dynamically imported module.

>From what I've read, I came to the conclusion that only `__file__`,
`__path__`, `__package__`, and `__name__` were used by the default
importer when determining the path of an import. Yet, I've verified
these in the code below, and it still fails when dynamically imported.
(It works when imported in the interpreter with an updated `sys.path`)

	# File structure:
	# [root]
	#  ├─ __init__.py
	#  ├─ board.py
	#  └─ test.py

	# Contents of 'board.py':
	import os, sys
	import root  # Already imported... just need a reference

	ROOT_DIR = os.path.dirname(root.__file__)
	assert root is sys.modules['root']
	assert root.__package__ is None
	assert root.__name__ == 'root'
	assert root.__file__ == os.path.join(ROOT_DIR, '__init__.py')
	assert not hasattr(root, '__path__')

	xx = object()
	assert xx is sys.modules['root.board'].xx
	assert __package__ is None
	assert __name__ == 'root.board'
	assert __file__ == os.path.join(ROOT_DIR, 'board.py')
	assert not hasattr(sys.modules['root.board'], '__path__')

	assert os.path.isfile(os.path.join(ROOT_DIR, 'test.py'))
	from . import test  # ImportError('cannot import name test',)

But if I hack `sys.path` and reimport the current package just before
the failed import, it works fine:

	oldroot = root
	del sys.modules['root']
	try:
		sys.path.append(os.path.dirname(ROOT_DIR))
		import root
	finally:
		sys.path.pop(-1)
	from . import test  # No error here

And further, the four golden attributes mentioned above are the same
in both the new and old packages:

	assert oldroot.__package__ == root.__package__
	assert oldroot.__name__ == root.__name__
	assert oldroot.__file__ == root.__file__
	assert not hasattr(root, '__path__')

Which means that `__package__`, `__name__`, `__file__`, and `__path__`
can't be the full story. Are there any other attributes that Python
uses to locate imports? What am I overlooking that would cause the
import to fail?



More information about the Python-list mailing list