List comprehensions and evaluation of elements therein

James Harris james.harris.1 at
Wed Sep 23 20:12:37 CEST 2015

A list comprehension has various components. Anyone know when each of 
the elements is evaluated? In the form

  [v0 for v0 in expr0 if expr1]

If v0 appears in expr0 or expr1 the evaluation order matters.

I think of the above as being a rewrite of

  results = []
  for v0 in expr0:
    if expr1:
  return results


  [v0, v2 for v0 in expr0 if expr1 for v2 in expr2 if expr3]

leads to

  results = []
  for v0 in expr0:
     if expr1:
        for v2 in expr2:
           if expr3:
              results.append((v0, v2))
  return results

First of all, is that a correct analog of the list comprehension?

With this latter expansion the values of v0 and v2 could appear in expr4 
or expr5. Again, the evaluation order would matter.


More information about the Python-list mailing list