[SciPy-User] zscore axis functionality is borked

[josef.pktd at gmail.com]

On Wed, Nov 30, 2011 at 3:45 PM,  <josef.pktd at gmail.com> wrote:
> On Wed, Nov 30, 2011 at 3:25 PM, Alacast <alacast at gmail.com> wrote:
>> axis=0 (the default) works fine. axis=1, etc, is clearly wrong. Am I
>> misunderstanding how to use this, or is this a bug?
>>
>> In [16]: i = rand(4,4)
>>
>> In [17]: i
>> Out[17]:
>> array([[ 0.85367762,  0.25348857,  0.23572615,  0.50403358],
>>        [ 0.70199066,  0.81872151,  0.47357357,  0.20425537],
>>        [ 0.31042673,  0.25837984,  0.73550134,  0.57970176],
>>        [ 0.42828877,  0.60988596,  0.04059321,  0.73944219]])
>>
>> In [18]: zscore(i, axis=0)
>> Out[18]:
>> array([[ 1.30128758, -0.96195723, -0.52119142, -0.01453907],
>>        [ 0.59653471,  1.38544585,  0.39284654, -1.55756529],
>>        [-1.22271057, -0.94164388,  1.39942427,  0.37494213],
>>        [-0.67511172,  0.51815526, -1.27107939,  1.19716222]])
>>
>> In [19]: zscore(i[:,0])
>> Out[19]: array([ 1.30128758,  0.59653471, -1.22271057, -0.67511172])
>>
>> In [20]: zscore(i[:,0])==zscore(i,axis=0)[:,0]
>> Out[20]: array([ True,  True,  True,  True], dtype=bool)
>>
>> In [21]: zscore(i, axis=1)
>> Out[21]:
>> array([[-0.99378502, -1.59397407, -1.61173649, -1.34342906],
>>        [-1.6379836 , -1.52125275, -1.86640069, -2.13571889],
>>        [-2.09968257, -2.15172946, -1.67460796, -1.83040754],
>>        [-1.29796925, -1.11637205, -1.68566481, -0.98681582]])
>> #The above is obviously wrong, as everything has a negative z score
>>
>> In [22]: zscore(i[0,:])
>> Out[22]: array([ 1.56824016, -0.83321371, -0.90428403,  0.16925757])
>>
>> In [23]: zscore(i[0,:])==zscore(i,axis=1)[0,:]
>> Out[23]: array([False, False, False, False], dtype=bool)
>> #Using axis=1 produces different results from taking a row directly.
>>
>> In [24]: zscore(i, axis=-1)
>> Out[24]:
>> array([[-0.99378502, -1.59397407, -1.61173649, -1.34342906],
>>        [-1.6379836 , -1.52125275, -1.86640069, -2.13571889],
>>        [-2.09968257, -2.15172946, -1.67460796, -1.83040754],
>>        [-1.29796925, -1.11637205, -1.68566481, -0.98681582]])
>> #Getting rows by using axis=-1 is no better (this is the same result as
>> axis=1
>
> This looks like a serious bug to me. I don't know what happened here (.
>
> The docstring example also has negative numbers only.
>
> ???
>
> I'm looking into it
>
> Thanks for reporting

a misplaced axis: if axis>0
then it calculates   x - mean/std instead of (x - mean) / std

now, how did this go through the testing ?

Josef

>
> Josef
>
>
>>
>>
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> SciPy-User mailing list
>> SciPy-User at scipy.org
>> http://mail.scipy.org/mailman/listinfo/scipy-user
>>