[Tutor] Division

Gregor Lingl glingl@aon.at
Mon, 3 Dec 2001 23:28:26 +0100


Thanks for this argument. I did some considerations
on this topic for myself.

My experience is, that my students understand well this
overloading of /, but they tend to forget it when writing
some useful programs doing some maths. Especially when
using the input-statement one often arrives at integers 
unintentionally. So should we type-cast every input with
float or resort only to use raw_input?

On the other hand the main point here is the difference between
two kinds of division, which of course must be taught - and perhaps
can be taught more easily - also in the python -Qnew interpreter.
If those two are accomplished by two different operators or
by a single overloaded one is -  IMHO ;-)  - secondary to that.

Thanks another time for the discussion

Gregor
 

----- Original Message ----- 
From: <alan.gauld@bt.com>
To: <tim.one@home.com>; <glingl@aon.at>; <tutor@python.org>
Sent: Monday, December 03, 2001 2:23 PM
Subject: RE: [Tutor] Division


> > > As I'm starting to give a new course 'Introduction to
> > > programming' in Jan 2002. It's for young students in the
> > > age of 15/16. (Of course) I shall use Python.
> > > I'd consider it an advantage not to confuse my students
> > > in the beginning with the specialities the overlaoding of 
> > > the division-operator (although I had to do so for several times
> > > until now). But neither with the import from future
> > > statement.
> 
> Just one point is that maybe for an education in programming 
> they should use the old style division behaviour - its how 
> the vast majority of programming languages work and is a 
> great way to seehow the computer is working under the covers.
> 
> If you want to use programming as part of another topic then 
> use new division but if you want to teach programming 
> principles stick to old style - its much more univesally 
> applicable and infornative IMHO.
> 
> Alan G
>