[Tutor] A better way to estimate the value of Pi?
steve at pearwood.info
Mon Oct 17 13:06:25 CEST 2011
Sagar Shankar wrote:
> Hi, this is my first question to this group. I'm a beginner to computer
> science and programming in Python. Am currently using John Zelle's book -
> Python Programming: An introduction to computer science to teach myself.
Hi Sagar, and welcome.
Can I ask you to please post code using plain text rather than HTML
email (also known as "rich text"), as HTML email messes up the
formatting? In this case, I can reverse-engineer the correct formatting,
so no harm done other than a waste of time, but that won't always be so
> In the book, there is an exercise to create a program that approximates the
> value of Pi by using the series [image: image.png]
> Now, the only way I've been able to figure out how to do this is by creating
> pairs of 4/x - 4/x+2 and calculating the series. The problem is that the
> exercise asks to prompt the user for the number of terms to sum, and then
> output the sum. So if an user inputs just 1, then his answer should be 4/1,
> whereas in my version it will 4/1-4/3
The series looks like:
4/1 - 4/3 + 4/5 - 4/7 + 4/9 - 4/11 +- ...
Three things stand out:
(1) The *numerator* of each term is always 4.
(2) The *denominator* of the terms are 1, 3, 5, ... or to put it another
way, the term in position i has denominator 2*i+1 (starting with i=0).
(3) The *sign* of the terms are +1, -1, +1, -1, +1, ... If you remember
your high school maths, (-1)**0 = +1, (-1)**1 = -1, (-1)**2 = +1, etc.
So the term in position i has denominator (-1)**i.
Putting those three things together, the term in position i (starting
with i=0) has value 4.0*(-1)**i/(2*i+1).
Does that help?
One other thing:
> import math
> seed = input("Please enter the number of pairs to calculate: ")
In Python 2, you shouldn't use input() for user input. It was a design
mistake, which has now been fixed in Python 3, but in Python 2 you
should use raw_input() instead.
The problem with input() is that it takes the user's input and *executes
it as code*, which could have all sorts of bad side-effects starting
with errors and just getting worse:
>>> name = input("What is your name? ")
What is your name? Steven
Traceback (most recent call last):
File "<stdin>", line 1, in ?
File "<string>", line 0, in ?
NameError: name 'Steven' is not defined
Instead, you should say this:
seed = int(raw_input("How many terms would you like? "))
More information about the Tutor