[XML-SIG] Ugh! Why are DOM access methods spelled with a leading
Sun, 25 Jun 2000 18:13:14 -0600
> On Sun, Jun 25, 2000 at 10:08:38AM -0600, Uche Ogbuji wrote:
> > > > Jim Fulton wrote:
> > > I've also looked at http://www.omg.org/cgi-bin/doc?ptc/00-01-12,
> > > which is similar and also leaves attribute mapping unspecified. :(
> > Just as a note to all, on the do-sig, Jim was already pointed to the right
> > clause in the Python/CORBA mapping, and Martin von Lowis also explained why it
> > is so (avoiding IDL name-clashes).
> > The remaining debate is whether to follow the Python/CORBA mapping. I say, no
> > reason not to do so. There is nothing normative about leading "_" being
> > private that I know of. It ends up being a question of style versus spec
> > unification, and I'm always wont to go for the latter.
> Nothing normative? Come on. That is simply an antagonistic position.
That is simply unfair.
> "from foo import *" is bad taste, but it codifies the notion of "_" being
> private. (symbols starting with "_" are not imported)
I was not aware of this (I never use from foo import *). It is definitely a
point in the leading-underscore-haters camp.
> Years and years of "_" usage meaning "private" also codify it. And you say
> "normative" ... what? Do we need to write an RFC to satisfy you? And do you
> also recognize that many things that occur in the RFC are there simply
> because they *ARE* de facto standards?
The use of leading "__" to indicate private is not in any RFC as I know it,
yet I'm understand it to be normative. So it's not so hard to convince me.
> I believe it is an entirely untenable position to state that "_" does not
> mean "private".
So you believe. Maybe you can make me believe the same.
> IMO, the Python/CORBA mapping is simply stupid if it demands leading
> underscores for any public item. Way stupid, and totally ignorant of
> Python's de facto standards.
Strongly stated, but hardly conclusive, I think. The "from foo import *" is
the closest you came to actually justifying why the Python/CORBA mapping is
"stupid". Even that, IMO, is not conclusive because it has about the strength
of its own obverse: "never use 'from foo import *'".
Uche Ogbuji Principal Consultant
firstname.lastname@example.org +01 303 583 9900 x 101
Fourthought, Inc. http://Fourthought.com
4735 East Walnut St, Ste. C, Boulder, CO 80301-2537, USA
Software-engineering, knowledge-management, XML, CORBA, Linux, Python