[Mailman-Users] HTML causing list-wide bounce?

[Michael Kabot]

Paul,

My apologies... The link got messed up, the HTML content of the email is at
http://www.soarol.com/tmp/EmailList-HTMLerror-2.txt.  The other link you saw
was a web page, which did have javascript and links to PayPal.

Excellent suggestion.  I will replace the -bounces address and see what I
get on Monday when I can get the customer to send more test messages.

I am not fluent in Qmail.  Finally found the logs for Qmail which was not in
the /var/log location, but rather deep under a Plesk directory.

The logs shows:
- the email coming into Mailman
- Mailman sending to each of the 3 list members
- my service provider's SMTP server (64.202.189.86) rejecting the message

Looks like you are right, just not my SMTP server rejecting it.

Am I reading these right?

Apr 13 12:10:05 mtws1 relaylock: /var/qmail/bin/relaylock: mail from [IP
PROTECTED]:6416 (mx5.[DOMAIN PROTECTED])
Apr 13 12:10:06 mtws1 qmail: 1176491406.512017 new msg 7808057
Apr 13 12:10:06 mtws1 qmail: 1176491406.512113 info msg 7808057: bytes 88145
from <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> qp 8993 uid 2020
Apr 13 12:10:06 mtws1 qmail: 1176491406.520469 starting delivery 102: msg
7808057 to local 127-sthtml at pack704.com
Apr 13 12:10:06 mtws1 qmail: 1176491406.520524 status: local 1/10 remote
0/20
Apr 13 12:10:06 mtws1 qmail: 1176491406.694746 delivery 102: success:
did_0+0+1/
Apr 13 12:10:06 mtws1 qmail: 1176491406.694895 status: local 0/10 remote
0/20
Apr 13 12:10:06 mtws1 qmail: 1176491406.694942 end msg 7808057
Apr 13 12:10:07 mtws1 relaylock: /var/qmail/bin/relaylock: mail from
127.0.0.1:58283 (localhost)
Apr 13 12:10:07 mtws1 qmail: 1176491407.760007 new msg 7808057
Apr 13 12:10:07 mtws1 qmail: 1176491407.760087 info msg 7808057: bytes 88547
from <elmont704p-sthtml-bounces at pack704.com> qp 9002 uid 2020
Apr 13 12:10:07 mtws1 qmail: 1176491407.778612 starting delivery 103: msg
7808057 to remote [LIST MEMBER #1]
Apr 13 12:10:07 mtws1 qmail: 1176491407.778706 status: local 0/10 remote
1/20
Apr 13 12:10:07 mtws1 qmail: 1176491407.778753 starting delivery 104: msg
7808057 to remote [LIST MEMBER #2]
Apr 13 12:10:07 mtws1 qmail: 1176491407.778796 status: local 0/10 remote
2/20
Apr 13 12:10:07 mtws1 qmail: 1176491407.778840 starting delivery 105: msg
7808057 to remote [LIST MEMBER #3]
Apr 13 12:10:07 mtws1 qmail: 1176491407.778883 status: local 0/10 remote
3/20
Apr 13 12:10:08 mtws1 qmail: 1176491408.245950 delivery 105: failure:
64.202.189.86_failed_after_I_sent_the_message./Remote_host_said:_554_Message
_refused./
Apr 13 12:10:08 mtws1 qmail: 1176491408.246040 status: local 0/10 remote
2/20
Apr 13 12:10:08 mtws1 qmail: 1176491408.287645 delivery 103: failure:
64.202.189.86_failed_after_I_sent_the_message./Remote_host_said:_554_Message
_refused./
Apr 13 12:10:08 mtws1 qmail: 1176491408.287696 status: local 0/10 remote
1/20
Apr 13 12:10:08 mtws1 qmail: 1176491408.325981 delivery 104: failure:
64.202.189.86_failed_after_I_sent_the_message./Remote_host_said:_554_Message
_refused./
Apr 13 12:10:08 mtws1 qmail: 1176491408.326036 status: local 0/10 remote
0/20
Apr 13 12:10:08 mtws1 qmail: 1176491408.355290 bounce msg 7808057 qp 9006
Apr 13 12:10:08 mtws1 qmail: 1176491408.355361 end msg 7808057
Apr 13 12:10:08 mtws1 qmail: 1176491408.356514 new msg 7808062
Apr 13 12:10:08 mtws1 qmail: 1176491408.356564 info msg 7808062: bytes 89388
from <> qp 9006 uid 2522
Apr 13 12:10:08 mtws1 qmail: 1176491408.364749 starting delivery 106: msg
7808062 to local 127-elmont704p-sthtml-bounces at pack704.com
Apr 13 12:10:08 mtws1 qmail: 1176491408.364803 status: local 1/10 remote
0/20
Apr 13 12:10:08 mtws1 qmail: 1176491408.544829 delivery 106: success:
did_0+0+1/
Apr 13 12:10:08 mtws1 qmail: 1176491408.544974 status: local 0/10 remote
0/20
Apr 13 12:10:08 mtws1 qmail: 1176491408.545021 end msg 7808062

  
In Service,
 
Michael Kabot
President - SOAR
  Scouting Online
    Affordable & Reliable
mkabot at soarol.com
585-388-0211

www.soarol.com 
 
 


| -----Original Message-----
| From: Paul Tomblin [mailto:ptomblin at xcski.com]
| Sent: Friday, April 13, 2007 5:49 PM
| To: mailman-users at python.org
| Subject: Re: [Mailman-Users] HTML causing list-wide bounce?
| 
| 
| > The email message causing the issue
| > -- .html format http://www.soarol.com/tmp/EmailList-HTMLerror-2.html
| 
| First comment - why the hell is he sending javascript in an
| email message? That plus the Paypal thing probably screams 
| "scammer" to most mail filters.  Because it's happening to 
| everybody, I'm betting it's an outgoing mail filter.
| 
| > SMTP Log is fine
| > -------------------------
| > Apr 13 12:10:07 2007 (2020)
| > <C42C157596C2E148A6C2B9335F1A223A01240F8C at ga016e0m12.<[EMAIL 
| > PROTECTED]>> smtp to elmont704p-sthtml for 3 recips, completed in 
| > 0.075 seconds
| > -------------------------
| 
| Where is the smtp log for the incoming bounces?  Better yet,
| replace the -bounces alias with a real mail address and have 
| a look at the bounce message.
| 
| 
| --
| Paul Tomblin <ptomblin at xcski.com> http://blog.xcski.com/
| "We must do something.  This is something.  Therefore we must 
| do this."
| - Military and Corporate Logic
| 
|