[Python-Dev] PEP: Use site-packages on all platforms

[Moore, Paul]

It was suggested that I post this to python-dev, as well as python-list and
the distutils SIG. I apologise if this is being done backwards? Should I get
a proper PEP number first, or is it appropriate to ask for initial comments
like this?

Paul

-----Original Message-----
From: Moore, Paul 
Sent: 30 March 2001 13:32
To: distutils-sig@python.org
Cc: 'python-list@python.org'
Subject: [Distutils] PEP: Use site-packages on all platforms


Attached is a first draft of a proposal to use the "site-packages" directory
for locally installed modules, on all platforms instead of just on Unix. If
the consensus is that this is a worthwhile proposal, I'll submit it as a
formal PEP.

Any advice or suggestions welcomed - I've never written a PEP before - I
hope I've got the procedure right...

Paul Moore

PEP: TBA
Title: Install local packages in site-packages on all platforms
Version $Revision$
Author: Paul Moore <gustav@morpheus.demon.co.uk>
Status: Draft
Type: Standards Track
Python-Version: 2.2
Created: 2001-03-30
Post-History: TBA

Abstract

    The standard Python distribution includes a directory Lib/site-packages,
    which is used on Unix platforms to hold locally-installed modules and
    packages. The site.py module distributed with Python includes support
for
    locating modules in this directory.

    This PEP proposes that the site-packages directory should be used
    uniformly across all platforms for locally installed modules.


Motivation

    On Windows platforms, the default setting for sys.path does not include
a
    directory suitable for users to install locally-developed modules. The
    "expected" location appears to be the directory containing the Python
    executable itself. Including locally developed code in the same
directory
    as installed executables is not good practice.

    Clearly, users can manipulate sys.path, either in a locally modified
    site.py, or in a suitable sitecustomize.py, or even via .pth files.
    However, there should be a standard location for such files, rather than
    relying on every individual site having to set their own policy.

    In addition, with distutils becoming more prevalent as a means of
    distributing modules, the need for a standard install location for
    distributed modules will become more common. It would be better to
define
    such a standard now, rather than later when more distutils-based
packages
    exist which will need rebuilding.

    It is relevant to note that prior to Python 2.1, the site-packages
    directory was not included in sys.path for Macintosh platforms. This has
    been changed in 2.1, and Macintosh includes sys.path now, leaving
Windows
    as the only major platform with no site-specific modules directory.


Implementation

    The implementation of this feature is fairly trivial. All that would be
    required is a change to site.py, to change the section setting sitedirs.
    The Python 2.1 version has

        if os.sep == '/':
            sitedirs = [makepath(prefix,
                                 "lib",
                                 "python" + sys.version[:3],
                                 "site-packages"),
                        makepath(prefix, "lib", "site-python")]
        elif os.sep == ':':
            sitedirs = [makepath(prefix, "lib", "site-packages")]
        else:
            sitedirs = [prefix]

    A suitable change would be to simply replace the last 4 lines with

        else:
            sitedirs = [makepath(prefix, "lib", "site-packages")]

    Changes would also be required to distutils, in the sysconfig.py file.
It
    is worth noting that this file does not seem to have been updated in
line
    with the change of policy on the Macintosh, as of this writing.

Notes

    1. It would be better if this change could be included in Python 2.1, as
       changing something of this nature is better done sooner, rather than
       later, to reduce the backward-compatibility burden. This is extremely
       unlikely to happen at this late stage in the release cycle, however.

    2. This change does not preclude packages using the current location -
       the change only adds a directory to sys.path, it does not remove
       anything.

    3. In the Windows distribution of Python 2.1 (beta 1), the
       Lib\site-packages directory has been removed. It would need to be
       reinstated.


Copyright

    This document has been placed in the public domain.

_______________________________________________
Distutils-SIG maillist  -  Distutils-SIG@python.org
http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/distutils-sig