[Mailman-Users] Member receives rejected message but message goesthrough

[Hung Phan]

Thank you, Mark

Here is the vette log for the most recent 3 days

Mar 07 00:44:22 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 07 02:11:49 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 07 02:23:29 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 07 07:42:36 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 07 12:18:14 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 07 12:51:27 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 07 23:12:35 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 07 23:18:09 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 07 23:22:21 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 08 09:04:04 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 08 16:55:13 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 08 17:32:15 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 08 19:17:24 2010 (2371) CHS_parents post from no- 
replyvixyc at ccu.edu held, message-id=<B41139DF.CBEF8711 at ccu.edu>: Post  
by non-member to a members-only list
Mar 09 00:40:12 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 09 01:25:22 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 09 02:49:22 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 09 07:25:57 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a
Mar 09 07:54:43 2010 (2371) Message discarded, msgid: n/a


Here is the post log for that particular post:
Mar 08 09:57:08 2010 (2373) post to csd_certified from calla at canby.k12.or.us 
, size=5515, message-id=<b8eadc911003080954r17a73e92iec9a1bb4f1cbc396 at mail.gmail.com 
 >, success




On Mar 8, 2010, at 11:08 AM, Mark Sapiro wrote:

> Hung Phan wrote:
>>
>> We have a moderated list with 325 members. The list is set to reject
>> post from moderated members with a custom rejected message. A member
>> is set to allow sending. Every time this person send message through
>> the list, it kicks back a rejected message to the user but the  
>> message
>> goes through. The reject message that the user receive is generic  
>> from
>> Mailman.
>
>
> Look in Mailman's vette log and find all the entries relevant to this
> user's post. If after that, you still don't know what's happening,
> post the vette log messages here,
>
>
>> We double-check and the user doesn't have the mod option checked. The
>> user is also enlisted in "List of non-member addresses whose postings
>> should be automatically accepted."
>
>
> If the user is a list member, moderated or not, putting the user's
> address in any of *_these_nonmembers is irrelevant because those apply
> only to addresses which aren't list members.
>
>
>> Where can we find the file that keep the user mod setting? Has anyone
>> experience this issue? Solution?
>
>
> The file is lists/LISTNAME/config.pck. You can look at it with
> bin/dumpdb, but I guarantee that you won't find anything there that
> contradicts what the list's admin Membership List shows you. The mod
> bit is the 2^7 (128) bit in the user's value in the user_options
> dictionary.
>
> -- 
> Mark Sapiro <mark at msapiro.net>        The highway is for gamblers,
> San Francisco Bay Area, California    better use your sense - B. Dylan
>